Is Jameela Jamil the right person to represent body positivity?

By Millie Fender
Deputy Editor

In recent months Jameela Jamil, radio presenter-turned-actress, seems to have become the unlikely poster child for the body positivity movement. Her high-profile critique of celebrities who promote products such as ‘detox teas’ grabbed headlines in November as she debunked the glorified laxatives and their harmful marketing for the impact they have on women. More recently, her exposure of an Avon advert for cellulite cream which claimed that ‘dimples are cute on your face (not your thighs)’ saw the removal of said marketing campaign. Another victory for the body positivity movement, surely?

It’s highly probable that I’m following a certain, liberal strain of media, but I can’t seem to go a day without scrolling past another article about Jameela Jamil and the blows she’s delivering to the ugly tactics of the beauty industry. For some, this might be the first they’ve heard of the body positivity movement. Countless online commentators have deemed her ‘refreshing’; a radical, feminist powerhouse.

To the marginalised women at the root of the movement, the fact that size ten model Jameela Jamil is fast becoming the poster child for body positivity leaves a sour taste in the mouth

However, the narrative Jamil preaches is far from original. The concept that we are so much more than what we weigh and that we should strive to love the skin we’re in has circulated social consciousness for decades. To the marginalised women at the root of the movement, the fact that size ten model Jameela Jamil is fast becoming the poster child for body positivity leaves a sour taste in the mouth.

This is not to say that women of certain sizes aren’t negatively affected by living in a society which tells us that we should be ashamed of our bodies- far from it, Jamil herself has spoken of her struggles with body-shaming and eating disorders, and I can’t begin to imagine the constant pressure which comes with such prominence in the public eye. However, the movement has its roots firmly planted in a movement for fat acceptance, whereby those whose body sizes fall outside the mainstream attempt to uplift each other in the face of daily abuse and microaggressions- something which Jamil herself accepts she can’t fully begin to understand.

The unwitting co-optation of this movement into the marketing ploys of companies such as Aerie and Dove has emerged in recent years as an arguably positive result of the movement. Certainly, we cannot criticise a company for halting its use of photoshop and airbrush- it’s definitely a step in the right direction for women everywhere. But if you’d like to see a flat-stomached, golden-skinned, dramatically curvaceous blonde’s trite attempts at showing beauty in some laughably forced stomach rolls I’d recommend checking out the Instagram of Iskra Lawrence, face of the AerieReal campaign. 

She herself has pleaded guilty to ignorance of body positivity’s multiplicity and intersections

Likewise, if you need a reminder that women do in fact have pores, feel free to check out Jamil’s twitter. The triumph of both body-positive icons, whether or not they can be held responsible for it, is ultimately at the expense of the fat women who created a movement, who still face the brunt of the damaging culture they attempt to confront.

Jamil is going to have to tread carefully if she is going to effectively represent a movement with its roots in fat acceptance from the position of little more than ally

In response to claims of outright appropriation, Jameela Jamil herself has conceded that she should not and never has attempted to be the face of the body positivity movement- calling such a suggestion “frankly, fucking ridiculous”. She claims that her @I_weigh movement seeks to uplift and give a voice to activists and marginalized groups by using her own privilege to initiate the conversation in newer and more public mediums, claiming “this is not me trying to steal your movement”. The attempt is without doubt well-meaning, refreshing and perhaps a needed leg-up to create more incisive change.

However, Jamil is going to have to tread carefully if she is going to effectively represent a movement with its roots in fat acceptance from the position of little more than ally. She herself has pleaded guilty to ignorance of body positivity’s multiplicity and intersections, and whether or not she’s trying to stand alongside us, not in front of us, I don’t see other body positive voices getting lauded on the cover of every major magazine.

There’s little more frustrating than seeing the narrative and language of a movement fostered in spite of the messages of mainstream media pedalled in trite and nonsubversive terms by that same opponent. Even if the media has genuinely bought into Jameela Jamil’s forward-thinking message, the truth is that it was never hers to sell in the first place.

Image by georgedarrel via Flickr.