Debate: should Hong Kong have full autonomy?
Hong Kong should not be an independent state
By Zoe Haylock
It is thought that independence always corresponds with freedom. Yet, life and politics is not that simple. Hong Kong was part of China and then ceded to Britain under the Treaty of Nanjing after the first Opium War. As Hong Kong was under Chinese control to begin with, should it rightfully not be independent from this state? This view, although perhaps pragmatic, omits any intricacies or notion of identity. To suggest that Hong Kong should be Chinese is morally dubious. When Hong Kong was handed back to China in 1997, the people were promised that their social and political freedoms would be retained. Yet, this has not become reality. Rights are continuously being restricted and the brutal government reaction to the Umbrella protests of 2014 shows that Hong Kong is now indisputably entrenched in Chinese Communist totalitarianism.
As Hong Kong was under Chinese control to begin with, should it rightfully not be independent from this state?
Referring back to the notion of identity, I think, is essential to this debate. It may be argued that the people of Hong Kong feel greatly aligned with British culture, and thus see themselves as part of this country. This identity cannot just be nullified, and a quick transition from being British or Chinese to being an independent state would be tricky, complex and perhaps unstable.
However, as a Brit, I do not see myself as qualified to hold much of an opinion. I think what is important is not whether Hong Kong should be independent but how best to protect the freedoms of its people. From this debate I wouldn’t really take away my opinion but the inspiration to formulate your own and listen to the people of Hong Kong, who ultimately are the ones whose voices should be heard.
Hong Kong’s Oppression Means it Must Have Independence
By Lydia Buckroyd
The mainland has continuously shown itself to be incapable of honouring the rights of the people of Hong Kong, and for that it should seek independence.
On the global stage, we like to see ourselves as the supporters of freedom in the face of authoritarian regimes. And yet where Hong Kong is concerned, the global community shuts its eyes. Never mind the fact that bookshop owners housing critical political books have disappeared, or that the legitimate election of pro-independence candidates has been blocked; since the 1997 handover, Hong Kong has been considered to be China’s issue and is therefore invisible to international concerns.
Ignoring the archaic colonialism of the handover itself, Hong Kong’s oppression means independence has become a necessity. Under the 1984 Sino-British Treaty that agreed the terms of the handover, it was agreed that Hong Kong should be maintained under the same ‘one country, two systems’ approach that Taiwan already enjoys. But this agreement has been steadily intruded upon. From China prosecuting activists to banning political parties, even the Chinese foreign minister declared the agreement a ‘piece of paper’ with ‘no practical significance’. The mainland has continuously shown itself to be incapable of honouring the rights of the people of Hong Kong, and for that it should seek independence.
Under the Human Rights charter of the UN, we accept the right to self-determination to be integral to all people. We declare it universally wrong for people to be restricted in their freedom of speech or opinion. So with all of these things happening in Hong Kong, it seems unreasonable to suggest that they should continue under China’s influence. The mainland’s creeping authority has proven that it cannot compromise in its control over the territory: in order to gain its rights, Hong Kong must gain its independence.
Image by Studio Incendo via Flickr
