A look at the election of Bolsonaro

Rhodri Sheldrake Davies

On the 29thof October 2018, Jair Messias Bolsonaro, the candidate for the ‘Partido Social Liberal’ (Social Liberal Party), was elected President of Brazil, taking more than 55% of the vote against rival Fernando Haddad of the ‘Partido dos Trabalhadores’ ‘(Worker’s Party). Brazil’s complex political situation and narratives about Bolsonaro himself have been continuously mischaracterised throughout this election, so here we’ll try to set the record straight.

The divisive now-President-elect has long been a political heavyweight in Brazilian establishment conservative and military circles. His career began in the Military in 1977, serving under the authoritarian ‘populist’ military dictatorship that lasted till 1985, which restrained freedom of speech, engaged in torture and banished any dissidents. In a 1998 article, Bolsonaro recounted his nostalgia for these years, which remained formative in his politics, and to this day his greatest on the record condemnation of this dictatorship was that it’s ‘mistake was to torture but not kill’.

His first public recognition came 1986, following an article he penned in Brazil’s ‘Veja’ magazine, criticising military leadership, which led to his arrest. Following acquittal some two years later, he joined the Military reserves at the rank of captain, and proceeded to run for the Rio de Janiero City Council, being elected in 1988. Subsequently, in 1990, as part of the Christian Social Party, he was elected as a representative to the lower chamber of the Brazilian Congress. He has since held this post for more than 30 years, being re-elected six times in affiliation with a variety of Conservative and Hard-right political parties. Bolsonaro has long held a foot in the door of the Political system of Brazil, and is keenly attuned to it. He represents the face of a well-established political force, with significant capital and experience, facets Trump and other ‘populist outsiders’ associated with the swing to the right in Europe and the US have lacked.

Throughout his career he has perpetuated racist stereotypes towards black Brazilians, expressed hatred for Brazil’s LGBT+ community, proclaiming himself a ‘proud homophobe’, and often resorted to misogynistic attacks on women.

The controversy surrounding Bolosnaro’s election, which led to widespread protests, and even an attempt on his life during the campaign, stems not only from his authoritarian tendencies but also from his consistent attacks on marginalised groups in Brazilian society. Throughout his career he has perpetuated racist stereotypes towards black Brazilians, expressed hatred for Brazil’s LGBT+ community, proclaiming himself a ‘proud homophobe’, and often resorted to misogynistic attacks on women. Unlike Trump, who generally falls back on dog-whistle tactics to pander to some of his more extreme right-wing support bases, Bolsonaro wears his violent rhetoric as a badge of honour; his personal website prominently featured videos of his abuse of a fellow congresswoman for example.

Bolsonaro’s rise to prominence is reflective of growing trend towards authoritarian and anti-democratic tendencies reborn in the political establishments across the globe, as seen already in Russia, India and Turkey. Through his election, he joins the ranks of the various authoritarian conservative ‘strongmen’ who have become associated with this now global trend.

With this in mind, we must ask, what has compelled Brazilians towards Bolsonaro?

Modern Brazil is a nation divided.

Modern Brazil is a nation divided. Following a crisis in 2014, its economy has suffered a serious depression. Though now entering a slow recovery, with a meagre growth of 1% in 2017, with the cost of living at an all-time high, damaged the prosperity of most Brazilians has been left seriously damaged. At the same time as this, violent criminality has soared, linked to the drugs trade and dwindling police resources, which necessitated the deployment of the military in several major cities to deal with record numbers of homicides and general unrest. These issues have played a major role in the election, generating disaffection with the incumbent Worker’s Party leadership and Brazil’s political establishment, with which Haddad, Bolsonaro’s presidential election rival, had closely associated himself.

This alienation has only been further exacerbated by‘operation carwash’. Originally an investigation into money laundering scheme, this quickly spiralled into a major corruption scandal investigating 232 people, many major political and business figures, and indicting 179, including former presidents Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva and Dilma Roussef. The fallout from this has been far from just political however, it has also involved more than $1 bn in misappropriated funds and a reimbursement request of $ 11.3 bn, leading to the closure of a variety of projects involving sixteen companies, in turn costing Brazil almost 500,000 jobs. Needless to say, this led to outcry as early as 2016, which has only intensified as the scope of the investigation has grown, leaving many Brazilians questioning the motives of the entire political class at a time when the nation has been struggling.

Bolsonaro’s message has been tailored as the ultimate snake-oil remedy to these woes

Bolsonaro’s message has been tailored as the ultimate snake-oil remedy to these woes: an alternative campaign promising ‘decisive’ and hard-line action against criminality, a novel neo-liberal reform of the economy, and the key promotion of a variety of anti-corruption pledges. He has built a perception of himself as simultaneously a ‘populist’ political outsider and a hard-line authoritarian strongman offering order in the face of turmoil. Despite warnings from academic and political commentators that this narrative is based on falsehood, and that in truth his policies may only fuel the flames of division further,Bolsonaro has still found success in using his ‘call to order’ to draw in support from a wide variety of bases who were already disaffected with the ‘old politics’ of his opponent Haddad.

Many Brazilians were prepared to look past the now-President-elect’s worrying social attitudes and autocratic militaristic tendencies, not because they endorse his vitriol, but because he has marketed himself as an ‘alternative’, with many seeing him as the last resort for a Brazil on the edge of turmoil. His election is indicative of widespread disenfranchisement with a democratic politics that has failed again and again to be accountable or responsive to the people it claimed to represent at all levels.

The worrying ramification of this however, is that it may well see Brazil join the growing list of nations that are turning away from democracy, and towards authoritarian strongmen, as the remedy for their woes.

Featured Image by Senado Federal via Flickr