Reviewed: Les Miserables

Jackman's Valjean and his ward, Cosette. Photograph: Universal Pictures
Jackman’s Valjean and his ward, Cosette. Photograph: Universal Pictures

by Jared Issacs – 4/5

An adaption of the longest running stage musical of all time (which I love), itself an adaption of a really long politically charged novel (which I love) has ended up being a film that has its flaws but is the best adaption of Les Mis on screen to date.

The much abridged plot is that Jean Valjean (Hugh Jackman) is released from prison after 19 years, having stolen a loaf of bread, and is perpetually hounded by the dogmatic Inspector Javert (Russell Crowe) after breaking parole. Valjean ends up taking in the daughter of Fantine (Anne Hathaway), Cosette (adult played by Amanda Seyfried), all of this is set in the backdrop of revolutionary era France with the major setpiece being the Paris uprising or June Revolution. Well that sounded very complicated and in truth it is, even if it is a distillation of the novel, but it fits together very nicely and makes sense in context.

So what is there to say? It’s big, bigger than the musical. Tom Hooper has chosen to do lots of sweeping shots and close-ups, which makes sense considering theatre can only provide the mid-shot and the opening scene of the prisoners hauling a ship into a dry dock, which although historically inaccurate, sets the scene and tone beautifully. The plot rests on Hugh Jackman’s Jean Valjean but there was never any doubt that he would not only carry the film but would be its solid rock foundation. What else would we expect from someone whose career started in musical theatre? He infuses Valjean with all the pathos and passion that is required. Whilst Jackman’s performance has garnered much talk, Anne Hathaway’s ‘I dreamed a dream’  has been on everyone’s lips and there is little more to say other than that she is fantastic in her share of the screentime; her rendition so raw and full of feeling that nary a dry eye is in the house.  Amanda Seyfried, Eddie Redmayne and Samantha Barks give solid performances with decent singing as Cosette, Marius and Eponine in their love triangle; and Sacha Baron-Cohen and Helena Bonham Carter are clearly having a great fun scene stealing as the villainous Thenardiers.

Valjean and Cosette's mother, played by Anne Hathaway. Photograph: Universal Pictures
Valjean and Cosette’s mother, played by Anne Hathaway. Photograph: Universal Pictures

The main flaw of the film is Russell Crowe’s Javert. How his singing ever got past a screen test is beyond me. He is clearly out of his depth singing with Jackman and is concentrating too much on trying to sing (and still not successfully) that he forgot that he also needed to act. The bizarre thing is that Crowe has done his fair share of musical theatre and singing but who knows how he managed to sell his music as his singing in Les Mis is god-awful. He is lucky that everyone else can carry him but it’s a shame that the antagonist gives such a weak performance.

The actual revolution/uprising was also perhaps a bit lacklustre in terms of size (the barricade is little more than a few chairs and is scaled with ease; good job guys) but the music is just so dramatic and emotional; made all the more so by the songs being all sung live.  Some have issue with everything being communicated through song but this is a musical – it is like take umbrage with a horror movie having a monster or fantasy being a bit hard to believe. If anything the singing enhances the feeling and drama of the characters.

Overall there are very good performances aside from Crowe’s, with particular praise going to Jackman and Hathaway; the music and drama is fantastic. It is long, but you cannot tell the size of a story like this spanning seventeen years without it being long nor should anyone be going into this thinking that this is a happy, sunshiny musical; this is a tragic, dramatic, deep, meaningful piece. A must see for any fan of the musical and recommended for anyone who wants to see something a bit different, especially since this is the best adaption of the novel and stage show yet.