Reviewed: Gangster Squad

Sean Penn devours the scenery as gangster Micky Cohen. Photograph: Warner Bros.
Sean Penn devours the scenery as gangster Micky Cohen. Photograph: Warner Bros.

by Frankie Humphreys – 4/5

Set in 1940’s Los Angeles, Gangster Squad is an all-star action thriller full of vice, corruption, bloody violence and all the other components you’d expect to find in a typical gangster movie. Though it’s predictable at times, the reviews have been a little too harsh on Ruben Fleischer’s crack at a different genre labeling the film as “slick but shallow” and “adolescent.” Actually, it is a remarkable achievement for a director used to dealing with wisecracking comedies, especially as it comes from a little known writer, Will Beall. Instead, Gangster Squad should be credited for magnificent cinematography at times and some brilliant performances from Josh Brolin, Ryan Gosling and Sean Penn (though this one’s controversial!)

A select team of cops is formed under Sergeant John O’Mara (Brolin) and, without the protection of their LAPD badges, charged with the task of waging war against the occupation of Micky Cohen in order to ‘save the soul of Los Angeles.’ The hand-picked gangster squad will go to any lengths to destroy the rapidly expanding empire of Cohen, who conveniently has the majority of LA officials wrapped around his little finger. Tactics get dirty and there is a momentary lapse in confidence when the ‘good cops’ struggle to see the difference between their actions and those of the gangsters – but that’s nothing a good machine gun shoot-out doesn’t resolve.

The opening scene sets the tone for the whole film, Brooklyn mobster Micky Cohen has a rival pulled apart by two Sedans underneath the sign for ‘Hollywoodland’.  This grotesque brutality is a little unnecessary but, then again, a gangster movie that didn’t overstep the line in this respect would be deemed tame and disappointing. Machine guns, grenades and acid all make their appearances throughout the film but things take an interesting turn when it all boils down to a simple bare knuckle fight (in a fountain, of course!)

Ryan Gosling is a particular standout in the cast. Photograph: Warner Bros.
Ryan Gosling is a particular standout in the cast. Photograph: Warner Bros.

Josh Brolin takes on the role of the Sergeant well, balancing the complex characteristics of a war hero accustomed only to fighting and a wannabe family man with a doting wife. He is supported by a surprisingly strong Ryan Gosling who plays Jerry Wooters – the young, heartbreaker cop who just so happens to be sleeping with Cohen’s girlfriend. The role most difficult to cast will have been Cohen himself. Personally, I think that Sean Penn does a superb job and I was captivated by his performance. He has been accused of carrying out the role ‘hammily’ – surely it’s impossible to play a hardcore gangster over-theatrically?

For a film that had to be drastically altered after filming due to last year’s July shootings in Colorado, Gangster Squad still packs a punch. I was not expecting a great deal, there’s only so many routes a director can take with a gangster movie and they all involve guns and violence, but I was pleasantly surprised. Two moments of outstanding cinematography mesmerized me to the degree of some Inception scenes, I was not expecting that! It’s unfortunate that Gangster Squad will be judged as ‘predictable’ by many and written off as a ‘nice try.’ I would suggest that everyone who goes to see Gangster Squad goes with an open mind, it’s easy to watch and, if you allow yourself to be transported to the 1940’s and absorbed by the period detail and exotic language, it’s thoroughly entertaining. This film could be the start of great things for Ruben Fleischer.