Reviewed: Great Expectations

by Eva Hodgkin – 3/5
A lone young boy stands before his parents’ grave; an escaped convict, just emerged from the murky Kentish marshes, grabs him by the shoulder. The opening to Dickens’ ‘Great Expectations’ has become one of the most iconic and oft-filmed set-pieces in twentieth century cinema. It is, perhaps, this sense of familiarity which hampers David Nicholls’ (of ‘One Day’ fame) newest adaptation from the outset; the inevitable comparisons, whether with the 1946 David Lean classic or the most recent, excellent, BBC miniseries last Christmas, give this latest attempt a slight feeling of going through the motions; the echoes of previous adaptations resound, even whilst the film is in progress.
Having said this, there is much to admire in Mike Newell’s (‘Four Weddings and a Funeral’) direction, which is expansive and rich, whether depicting the desolate gloom of the marshland, the glamorous decay of Satis House, which seems to be crumbling before the viewer’s eyes, or the chaotic sprawling mass of 19th century London. The essence of Dickens’ bildungsroman, describing Pip’s rise from blacksmith’s apprentice to snobbish young man-about-town, remains as captivating as ever; it is hard, even when you know exactly what’s coming, not to be caught up in the power of the plot. Its themes, in particular concerning the destructive effect of attaching disproportionate value to wealth, are as relevant in our post-recession society as they were to Dickens’, in the throes of industrialisation.

Moreover, even though they are characters we feel we know well, the quality of the acting is still evident. Jeremy Irvine’s Pip ‒ the younger Pip played by his younger brother ‒ has the right air of wide-eyed wonder and goodness to retain our support even when he is at his most ungrateful and snobbish; it is a much more thoughtful portrayal than his other leading turn, in ‘War Horse’. His general look is also more convincing than Douglas Booth’s distractingly beautiful, slightly pouty Pip from the 2011 serial; it is easier to imagine Irvine feeling at home in the forge. Similarly Helena Bonham Carter feels an utterly natural choice for Miss Havisham, managing to preserve a sense of vulnerability amidst the theatricality and melodrama. Ralph Fiennes’ Magwitch is good, but feels perhaps a little consciously thespian when compared to Ray Winstone’s authentically rough, lived-in version of last year. All the supporting roles are near-perfect, whether Jason Flemyng as the warm-hearted, gentle Joe Gargery or Ewen Bremner showing Wemmick’s attempt to separate home and office life.
In short, this is a successful production which falls short only because it fails to differ in any real way from the myriad versions which have gone before; it feels more a reiteration than a fresh adaptation. This is not an inevitable pitfall of covering well-loved classics; as other recent adaptations such as Joe Wright’s ‘Anna Karenina’ or Cary Fukunaga’s ‘Jane Eyre’ have shown, it is still possible to give a novel take on a much-told tale. However lavishly put together and well-acted, this latest attempt offers little to differentiate it from the crowd, a fact perhaps unfairly evident given its uncomfortable proximity to the recent BBC effort. It is extremely enjoyable viewing, compromised only by its unwillingness to risk attempting something new.
