Review: Waitress (Sunderland Empire)

By Alex Roy

Rating: 5 out of 5.

There is something special about returning to a show that once meant everything to you, only to find that it now means something different, and arguably even more. Waitress has long held that place in my theatrical psyche. My love for it began in summer 2019 at the Adelphi Theatre, where it became the first show I ever logged on Mezzanine, its score soundtracking some of the most formative moments teenage years. To encounter it again now, on its 10th Anniversary tour at the Sunderland Empire a whole seven years later, proves just how deeply this musical endures.

At its core, Waitress tells the story of Jenna Hunterson, a waitress and expert pie-maker navigating an unhappy marriage, an unexpected pregnancy, and a complicated relationship with her doctor, Dr Pomatter. What unfolds is a narrative steeped in contradiction — morally complex yet deeply compassionate, and heartbreakingly devastating yet consistently hilarious. It is precisely this balance that underscores the piece’s narrative strength. Jessie Nelson’s book and Sara Bareilles’ score work in seamless tandem, crafting a world in which the humour at the heart of the musical sits alongside the pain as an essential counterpart, never once undercutting it. In this sense, the emotional register of the show is remarkably controlled; it moves between lightness and gravity with a precision that ensures neither is diminished.

That sense of emotional poignancy is carried through in the performances, beginning with Durham’s own Emma Lucia as Jenna. Her portrayal is defined by a striking sensitivity, grounding the character’s internal conflict in something palpably real. Her considered characterisation of Jenna boasts a careful build towards the intermittent moments of emotional release. Her ‘She Used to Be Mine’ is beautifully devastating in its restraint, while ‘What Baking Can Do’ lands with an emotional clarity.

Their dynamic is effortless, the humour emerging organically from effective characterisation

Alongside her, Sandra Marvin’s Becky and Evie Hoskins’ Dawn form a trio that is boundlessly compelling. Marvin brings a sharp comedic instinct to Becky, her delivery laced with a sassy wit, while Hoskins’ Dawn is all endearing awkwardness, played with impeccable timing. Their dynamic is effortless, the humour emerging organically from effective characterisation.

Mark Anderson’s Ogie provides some of the production’s most joyous moments, his performance brimming with energy and precision. ‘Never Ever Getting Rid of Me’ is a standout, not simply for its vocal strength but for the clarity of its comedic construction — each moment carefully calibrated for maximum effect. In contrast, Mark Willshire’s Earl is genuinely unsettling, his presence carrying a weight that underscores the darker undercurrents of the narrative. Dan Partridge’s Dr Pomatter offers a delicate counterbalance: awkward, earnest, and vocally assured, he captures the character’s contradictions with care.

The ensemble, too, proves indispensable. While there is often debate surrounding their necessity in Waitress, their inclusion here feels entirely justified. They facilitate the fluidity of the production — seamless transitions and a constantly animated diner space — while also enriching the world of the play. Olivia Lallo stands out in particular, bringing a consistent vitality to each moment she inhabits.

Star casting too is often met with a degree of scepticism, yet is something Waitress consistently utilises — this is arguably contentious given its tonal delicacy. However, Les Dennis proves a remarkable Joe. Boasting much of the heart of the production, he anchors the story in a raw, unvarnished realism that cuts through the musical’s lighter textures. His Joe is not overly sentimentalised, nor played for easy sympathy; instead, Dennis leans into the character’s brusqueness and fragility, allowing moments of warmth to emerge with an earned sincerity.

Visually, the production remains faithful to its origins while adapting intelligently for the demands of touring

Visually, the production remains faithful to its origins while adapting intelligently for the demands of touring. Scott Pask’s design retains the iconic checkerboard floor and utilises a subtle LED backdrop to enhance the palette of the piece without overwhelming it. The set’s mobility allows for swift, unobtrusive transitions, though the occasional reliance on a black curtain to mask larger changes momentarily disrupts the illusion. This, however, is a minor quibble in an otherwise cohesive design that honours the spirit of the original.

One of the production’s most distinctive features — the onstage band — remains as effective as ever. Integrated into the action through Suttirat Anne Larlarb’s costuming, they become part of the fabric of the world rather than an external addition. The Act 2 wedding sequence exemplifies this integration beautifully. Musically, the band handles Bareilles’ score with a warmth and clarity that reinforces its emotional impact; it is a reminder of just how rich and textured this music is when experienced live.

Direction, originally by Diane Paulus, with resident director Nikki Davies-Jones, continues to shape the production with a clear and confident hand. The balance between Jenna’s internal world and the external narrative is carefully maintained, with dream-like sequences slipping seamlessly into reality. In a piece that juggles multiple storylines, this coherence is no small achievement. Choreography, by Lorin Latarro, complements this vision, making inventive use of props and movement to sustain the production’s momentum without overwhelming its intimacy.

It goes without saying that Waitress is absolutely a must-see show; it is a musical that understands what it is to be human. It is also everything a good musical should be: messy, funny, painful, hopeful all at once. I have already booked tickets to return to the Sunderland Empire this week to catch it again, and you should too.

Waitress is running at the Sunderland Empire until Saturday 9th May, 2026. Get your tickets here.

Image: Matt Crockett.