Review: Avenue Q
By Lucy Atkinson
We almost didn’t see Avenue Q on the West End — it was a spontaneous decision to buy the cheap tickets left at the Shaftesbury Theatre for that evening with so-called ‘restricted view’ (which, as it turned out, were completely fine). I’m so glad we did, as the show’s chaotic charm is almost made for spur-of-the-moment viewing.
Instead, it trusts the audience to understand the satire, while making just enough adjustments to keep things feeling current rather than uncomfortable
The original source material admittedly has its themes of ‘anti-wokeness’ before such a term even existed, and I was genuinely curious (and slightly apprehensive) about how the team would navigate those more ‘eek’ moments in today’s political and cultural climate. What’s impressive is that the production doesn’t attempt to sand down its edges entirely. Instead, it trusts the audience to understand the satire, while making just enough adjustments to keep things feeling current rather than uncomfortable.
The changes are refreshingly few and far between, with slight updates to outdated pop culture — such as David Hasselhoff being replaced with Benedict Cumberbatch in Rod’s dream about Nicky — alongside references to things like ChatGPT, Grindr and OnlyFans, which are sprinkled in with a surprising level of restraint. They land as knowing winks rather than desperate grabs for relevance, allowing the script to retain its original bite without feeling stuck in a 2003 time capsule.
Flowers absolutely have to be given to the two leads, Emily Benjamin (Kate Monster and Lucy the Slut) and Noah Harrison (Princeton and Nicky). Obviously, any lead role in a show on this scale would be challenging, but to slip seamlessly not only between distinct vocal performances but also the physical language of entirely different puppets is something else entirely. Benjamin, in particular, demonstrates extraordinary control — her ability to switch between Kate’s earnest warmth and Lucy’s brazen confidence is both technically impressive and consistently funny. Harrison matches this versatility with equal precision, giving Princeton an endearing awkwardness while imbuing Nicky with his stuck-up charm.
That level of synchronicity across the cast speaks to an exceptional ensemble effort
What’s perhaps most striking is how invisible the mechanics of puppetry become in the show. Moments where characters are logistically handed between performers could easily break the illusion, but here they barely register. That level of synchronicity across the cast speaks to an exceptional ensemble effort, and it’s especially evident during ‘Special’, as well as the brilliantly executed scene where Benjamin essentially performs opposite herself. It’s a sequence that could feel gimmicky, but instead plays as one of the sharpest and most engaging moments in the show.
Another standout performance comes from Amelia Kinu Muus as Christmas Eve — a character that, in earlier iterations, leaned heavily into caricature. Here, she is thoughtfully and tastefully humanised. You can immediately sense that Muus’ own Japanese identity has informed this portrayal, grounding the role in something far more authentic and layered. The comedy is still very much present, but it’s no longer at the expense of the character; instead, it feels rooted in personality and circumstance, which ultimately enriches the story as a whole.
Dionne Ward-Anderson’s Gary Coleman is sassy, hilarious, and a genuinely warm presence throughout the show. There’s a natural ease to her performance that makes the character feel less like a punchline and more like the beating heart of the Avenue itself — someone who has seen it all and chooses humour anyway. Her delivery is sharp without ever feeling forced, and she brings a sense of rhythm to the comedy that keeps the audience constantly engaged. Vocally, she’s just as strong; her performance of ‘Schadenfreude’ is a real highlight, packed with clarity, attitude, and just the right amount of bite. It’s one of those moments where the show’s message and musicality align perfectly, leaving a lasting impression long after the number ends.
Ultimately, Shaftesbury’s Avenue Q proves that it hasn’t lost the very thing that made it resonate in the first place: its ability to be both disarmingly funny and quietly incisive. This production strikes a careful balance between preserving the show’s original irreverence and acknowledging the tastes and judgement of a contemporary audience, without ever feeling diluted or overly cautious. What emerges is a version of Avenue Q that feels alive — self-aware, but not self-conscious — and still deeply invested in its central idea that navigating adulthood is messy, uncertain, and often absurd. It’s a show that meets you where you are, makes you laugh at things you probably shouldn’t, and then leaves you with something unexpectedly sincere, and in a West End landscape that can sometimes feel overly polished, there’s something refreshing about a piece that embraces its rough edges and reminds us why they mattered in the first place.
Image credit : Matt Crockett

