Review: Hamilton (Sunderland Empire)

By Sophie Midlane

Rating: 5 out of 5.

On Friday, I had the privilege of attending the press night of Hamilton’s UK Tour stop at the Sunderland Empire Theatre. Set against the backdrop of the American fight for independence from Britain, the musical explores the cost of ambition and obsessive pursuit of legacy, as embodied by its namesake, Alexander Hamilton. Lin-Manuel Miranda, the show’s visionary writer and lyricist, delivers a compelling ‘rags-to-riches’ retelling of Hamilton’s rise from immigrant outsider to the first U.S. Secretary of the Treasury. Blending passion, despair, and sharp humour with a vibrant mix of rap, hip-hop, and rhythmic melodies, Hamilton offers a bold and exhilarating exploration of the highs and lows of the pursuit of the American Dream. 

Marley Fenton leads the company with tireless charisma and clarity in the title role. From the opening number, he is in constant motion—traversing the stage like a man racing time. “There’s a million things I haven’t done,” he insists, and you believe him. His Hamilton is hungry, stubborn, and always slightly out of breath—a portrait of genius in overdrive. Opposite him, Billy Nevers offers a compelling Aaron Burr: watchful, restrained, and softly simmering. Nevers leans into Burr’s self-doubt with understated power, making his final cry—“Now I’m the villain in your history”—land with devastating resonance.

Transforming heartbreak into quiet rage

The show’s vocal strength across the cast is, frankly, phenomenal. Casey Al-Shaqsy is a clear standout as Eliza Hamilton, bringing vocal purity and emotional heft to Helpless and later, in Burn, transforming heartbreak into quiet rage. Naomi Katiyo, as Maria Reynolds, seduces both Hamilton and the audience with subtle control and smoky tone, while Shaka Mansfield James impresses in dual roles as John Laurens and Hamilton’s son, Phillip, injecting both characters with youthful vibrancy and unfiltered charm. Jago Mottart deserves a special mention for his uproarious turn as Charles Lee, injecting levity into Act I and drawing delighted laughter from the crowd.

Much of Hamilton’s power lies not only in its performances but in its visual language. The ensemble work is thrilling—precise, athletic, and deeply expressive. Choreographically (Andy Blankenbuehler), this production is razor-sharp. Dance becomes an extension of narrative: stillness conveys status, while bursts of movement underscore musical accents or emotional tension. The use of slow-motion and “rewind” during key moments—particularly in the duel scenes and in Satisfied—highlights the show’s intricate temporal structure and Miranda’s lyrical genius. The occasional spacing issues in the ensemble didn’t undercut the overall cohesion; their stamina and spatial awareness were vital in maintaining momentum across two and a half breathless hours.

The revolving stage, used with finesse, gives the show a cinematic flow—scenes shift with a fluidity that mirrors Hamilton’s own urgency. Costuming by Paul Tazewell is period-rooted yet stylised, with rich fabrics that catch the light beautifully. Hair design (Charles Lapointe), often overlooked, subtly contributes to the movement and rhythm of the choreography—an elegant detail that pays off. Lighting designed by Howell Binkley is employed with precision: amber hues for candlelit confessionals, stark white washes for political combat.

The band is faultless, with musical direction by Zach Flis

Musically, the band is faultless, with musical direction by Zach Flis. The orchestration crackles with energy, shifting seamlessly from rap battles to ballads, from cabinet meetings to battlefield declarations. The layering of hip-hop, R&B, and classic musical theatre motifs is handled with polish and purpose.

Hamilton is not just a spectacle; it’s a story of flawed people making flawed choices, and the ripples those choices create. What this touring production captures so well is the feeling – that blend of fire, failure, and hope – that has made the show a cultural touchstone. It’s loud, lyrical, and unapologetically earnest.

Thank you to the Sunderland Empire for hosting such a stunning evening, and looking after us so well. Hamilton runs until 26th July, and if ever there were a time to want to be in the room where it happens – this is it. Get your tickets here.

Image credit – Danny Kaan