How can the Conservatives re-build?

By Oliver Watterson

Discovering why the last general election was so spectacularly lost by the Conservatives is as relevant today as it was on July 5th last year. The answer determines what the Conservatives should do to try and improve their ever-dwindling poll ratings. As the local election results show, the Conservatives face an existential threat, losing seats to all sides, to Reform but also to the Lib Dems. Should the Conservatives – as they appear to be doing – continue attempting to ‘out-Farage’ Farage or should they adopt a more moderate, centrist approach?  

After a year, there seems to be a consensus among the current Conservative frontbench as to why they are now in opposition. It is argued that they were not ‘conservative enough’, but too liberal, losing their core conservative base to Reform on issues such as immigration. This could certainly be true. After all, Kemi Badenoch, along with leadership hopeful Robert Jenrick, certainly accept this diagnosis. They argue that this failure of their time in government continues to be the reason for their disastrous polling, notably marked by the recent local elections.

Accepting this would suggest that the rise of Reform was precipitated by the Conservatives’ failure in this regard. Robert Jenrick has described Reform as “a symptom not a cause”, stating that “it exists …because my party [the Conservatives] failed.”

But is the argument that the Conservatives lost because they failed to govern as ‘proper conservatives’ actually true? 

“Former Prime Minister Theresa May [has argued] that the Conservatives lost because the party ‘trashed its brand'”

Former Prime Minister Theresa May argued the opposite, arguing that the Conservatives lost because the party “trashed its brand”, losing its reputation for “integrity and competence”. Liz Truss’ mini-budget shattered the Conservatives’ reputation for economic competence and the Partygate scandal undermined integrity. By veering further and further to the right to appease potential Reform voters, the Tories forgot, in Theresa May’s words, that they are “not a right-wing party but a centre-right party.” By forgetting this, the Conservatives let ‘Reform-appeasing policy’ poisonously infect what was the Conservative’s winning characteristic: that the party is a safe pair of hands for competent, sound government.

By attempting to ‘out-Farage Farage’, the Conservatives failed – and continue to fail – to do so. Why would a Reform voter vote for a Reform copy-cat? However, by losing their reputation for sound, competent government in the process, they simultaneously lost chunks of the South West and the ‘financially-affluent heartlands’ to the Lib Dems. Former Tory strong-holds like Maidenhead – the former seat of Theresa May herself – were swept up by the Lib Dems. This is a very different diagnosis from the one outlined above, that the Conservative’s lost for not being right wing enough. 

So, what can the Conservatives do next? Accepting the argument that the Conservatives lost because they lost the centre-ground (by losing their reputation for competence), the inevitable solution is to reclaim this. George Osbourne argues Kemi Badenoch should focus less on ‘fringe issues’ such as culture wars, and more on ‘core’ issues of public policy, namely the economy, health and education. Mel Stride’s recent speech on economic prudence shows that some spades are being put in the ground to reclaim their electoral winning reputation of economic competence. Reform’s recent policies, including abolishing the two-child benefit cap, is a far cry from the fiscally competent ‘conservative brand’ which used to win the Tories elections. Rather than chasing Reform, Reform has left the Conservatives a gap in the political market, and a chance to distinguish themselves. Reform now appeals to a very different audience in the Labour heartlands, in which the Tories are a toxic brand. Whilst these voters lent the Tories their vote in 2019 to deliver Brexit, this was temporary. Cameron and Thatcher won without this ‘red-wall’ voter base. If the Conservatives continue to chase Reform, failing to fulfil the gap Reform have left, veering ever further from the centre-ground, it is very arguably the case that they will merely play into Reform’s hands, losing seats to all sides, ceasing to have any relevance.

Image: UK Government via Wikimedia Commons