Review: ‘Five Kinds of Silence’
By Sophie Boddington

Five Kinds of Silence is an unflinchingly raw, moving, and disturbing play in equal measure, and none of these qualities make for an easy or enjoyable theatre-going experience. As Director Aaron Rozanski writes in his Director’s Note, “Shelagh Stephenson forces us to listen.” This much is undeniably true. Suffragette Theatre Company’s production is full of force – emotional force and creative force. Like all forceful performances, however, this runs the risk of heavy-handedness and a neglect of fine-tuning, which Five Kinds of Silence does not always avoid. Nevertheless, with a highly talented cast and the newly renovated Assembly Rooms at his disposal, Rozanski has a created a paired-back but powerful production which lays bare the complex workings of an abuse-stricken household.
Five Kinds of Silence explores the life of Billy, both a perpetrator and victim of abuse, and the effect of this on his wife, Mary, and his two daughters, Susan and Janet. Although Billy’s character, played ably by both Oscar Nicholson and Thomas Bracewell, effectively commands the stage, Rozanski’s decision to focus on the “fully realised female protagonists” is thoughtful one, and thoroughly achieved, with Giorgia Laird, Martha Wrench, and Helena Baker deftly demonstrating the familial ties which bond them together.
Across the board, the cast work hard to provide sensitive performances, and there is a clear sense of kinship and chemistry throughout. However, there are several who excel beyond the high bar that is set. Helena Baker as youngest daughter Janet offers a harrowing performance, with every aspect of her portrayal, from her brittle and composed dialogue to her sudden outpouring of grief, creating a highly believable and sympathetic character. Likewise, Thomas Bracewell as Billy 2 showcases incredible range and commitment to the role, dominating the stage with his presence and vocal capabilities, managing to captivate the audience with a single well-timed whisper even more than his thundering shouts.
While the production undeniably has its flaws, I feel most of these can be remedied with further polish which will come from successive performances. The background music, for instance, creates an unsettling atmosphere but is played at such a volume that, even sitting on the third row from the front, I am unable to hear Nicholson’s initial monologue. In a similar vein, the transitions between scenes felt clunky and forced, and longer blackouts would have spared the audience from jarring choreography, like Bracewell’s deceased Billy standing up to change position. These issues, though, are slight, and do not heavily detract from the accomplishments of the actors.
A play which depicts such controversial and haunting subjects as rape, incest, and murder, is unlikely to be one which a student production negotiates flawlessly. Some directorial choices, however, are particularly difficult to fathom. In student theatre, where actors are all typically of a similar age, use of costume is arguably one of the easiest ways to differentiate between the ages and social roles of characters. Therefore, clothing Laird’s character, the maternal Mary, in a mini skirt doesn’t seem the wisest idea.
Five Kinds of Silence is not an enjoyable play. But if you wish to see a production that showcases some of Durham’s finest student acting, that will make you question the way society operates, and will most likely bring a lump to your throat, I highly recommend Suffragette Theatre Company’s most recent offering.
Image by Rahul Shah
