Review: ‘The Babbling Barista Monologues’

By Sophie Boddington

In recent years, theatre on many levels has been dominated by bleak, heavy-handed productions all too eager drive a message home. To this, Pitch Production’s The Babbling Barista Monologues, written and directed by Natasha Ali, offers the perfect antidote. Much like a good cup of coffee, the production contrasts sweetness with a handful of deeper and more bitter moments. Rounded off with a healthy dose of frothy comedy, this play is sure to appeal to anyone wishing to escape the pressures of impending deadlines for an hour of silly, quirky fun.

The venue could not be more ideal: the cosy ambience and fixtures of Cafédral effortlessly recreate the location of the fictionalised ‘Sunducks’ – renamed for copyright reasons, we are playfully informed – albeit with more charm and personality than the corporate chain in question. Thoughtful touches such as the invented ‘Sunducks’ logo stuck on the coffee cups and affixed to the aprons set the entertaining and fourth wall-breaking tone of the production.

The production truly shines when they work in tandem

The restricted space and intimacy of the venue is not without its flaws, unfortunately; due to the lack of a raised stage, some characters spend long moments, even entire conversations, without being fully lit, which is a real shame as we miss out on some of the subtler moments of expression and body language. I hope that the production team can rectify this for the next performance as I do feel it limited the characters’ more dynamic interactions. Nevertheless, the cast are unfazed by this slight hiccup, and the production truly shines when they work in tandem. Initially, I thought the four characters would provide little more than basic archetypes. However, as each character is given their moment to reflect, it was nice to see hints of deeper nuance between them.

As the author avatar, it is the task of Ella Al-Khalil Coyle as Ruth to weave together the various anecdotes, complaints and conversations of the other characters, and she does so with aplomb. Her energy is infectious throughout the performance, though it is some of her quieter moments that are most relatable, like her palpable disappointment every time she is ignored by the senior baristas.

Anthony Ford as Marvin likewise has great presence on stage, and gains some of the biggest laughs of the night in his overemotional monologue about memorable customers, and I had to laugh even as he continued to breathe heavily minutes after his outburst.

As Carine, Isabella Thompson delights with her sarcastic delivery and finely tuned wit; her sneer is a work of art and she is thoroughly entertaining in her unfaltering commitment to her cynical character. Though the cliché of ‘acting is reacting’ is a tired one, it certainly holds true with Thompson’s portrayal; she is always ready with an eye-roll or a snarky quip. Her back-and-forth with Matthew Redmond’s Arwin is particularly enjoyable as the two verbally spar about their work motivations.

A reminder to be nicer to baristas everywhere

Redmond’s character initially appears to be written as the most one-dimensional of the group – the typical Dwight Schrute figure – but subverted my expectations as inner conflict over his most traumatic barista experience is revealed. Redmond showcases considerable acting chops as he manages to make his uptight supervisor one of the most sympathetic figures.

Proceeded by a sudden and hilarious burst of complaining from the group, the play’s ending might have very easily drifted into sickly-sweet territory, were it not for the cast’s acknowledgement of this very fact. In this way, it is similar to the rest of the script, which could admittedly use a bit of a polish. In the monologues, the dialogue has the tendency to teeter into expository cliché, and for this reason I suspect that it may not be everyone’s cup of tea (or coffee, in this case). Further editing might cut down some of the longer speeches, and clunkier phrasing and references to focus on the interactions between characters, which are by far the most entertaining moments. Nevertheless, as Ali notes that it was changed from a one-woman show to a four-person script in a frantic fortnight, so I will refrain from judging too harshly!

A perfectly digestible foray

I think what I most enjoy is that at no point does The Babbling Barista Monologues attempt to be anything more than it is: there is no preachy lesson to be learnt, except, perhaps a reminder to be nicer to baristas everywhere. It is simply a story about a group of workers who want their voices to be heard. Clocking in at just over an hour, The Babbling Barista Monologues provides a perfectly digestible foray into the antics, challenges, and tight-knit community of a service employee, and an evening of entertaining student-written comedy.  

Image: Pitch Productions