Abortion is finally legal in Northern Ireland: but why has it taken so long?
By Pip Murrison
Historic new laws decriminalising abortion in Northern Ireland went into effect at midnight
on the 21st of October, following a vote in July with a majority of 332 to 99 in Westminster.
This means that women in Northern Ireland finally have the basic human right of female
bodily autonomy and can terminate a pregnancy without fear of being prosecuted. Services
will be introduced into Northern Ireland by the 1 st of April 2020, meaning those seeking an
abortion will no longer have to travel abroad. Instead, terminations will be provided at two
hospital sites within the country.
This brings Northern Ireland in line with both the rest of the UK, where under the Abortion
Act of 1967, access to abortion was made possible, and with the Republic of Ireland, who
voted overwhelmingly in a 2018 referendum to lift the ban.
No matter how monumental the vote may appear to Pro-Choice campaigners, the victory
is bittersweet. Many Pro-Life campaigners see that they have grounds to contest the
decision as it was taken by a Westminster government, not by a Northern Irish one at
Stormont.
Durham Students for Life group commented, ‘the key principal, that local people can more
effectively make laws for themselves rather than a national government, has been swept
aside by Westminster in forcing abortion on Northern Ireland.’
The largest party in Northern Ireland, the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP), have likewise
condemned the results, with their leader Arlene Foster labelling the 22nd as a ‘shameful day’
and vowed to try ‘every possible legal option’ to block the new law coming into force.
Such was their despair at the prospect of the decriminalisation of abortion that Northern
Ireland’s assembly sat for the first time in almost over three years. The DUP and politicians
from some other unionist parties came together to make a last-ditch attempt to stop the bill
coming into effect.
Although this move was always going to be symbolic with Sinn Féin described it as
‘pantomime politics,’ as the assembly cannot act without an elected speaker, the fact that
the assembly sat having been suspended since 2017 gave a strong message back to
Westminster – the bill had been ‘imposed’ upon them. ‘There is no way that [the abortion
bill] would pass through the Assembly in Northern Ireland’, Arlene Foster concluded.
Naomi Clarke, a student at Durham and Northern Irish citizen remarked that it was
‘infuriating that trying to suppress these human rights was what ignited some Northern Irish
MLA’s to get back to work after an absence of over 1000 days, still on full pay and expenses
funded by tax payer’s money.’
Pro-Life groups may be demanding the revocation of calling to revoke Westminster’s
decision, but polls show that 65% of adults from Northern Ireland agree that abortion should not be a crime, and 66% said that in the absence of a devolved government, Westminster should legislate to reform the law.
Although Stormont has been bypassed, Westminster has been used as a channel to revoke
an act passed in 1861 which falls foul of human rights held by the rest of the UK and of
popular opinion across Northern Ireland.
In an ideal world, the Northern Irish Assembly would be able to legislate such matters for
themselves, making the bill more watertight and the grounds of argument of the Pro-Life
campaign void. However, this has not been possible whilst Sinn Féin and the DUP continue
to put their rift above representing the views of their people.
‘I would now like to hope that talks could potentially resume in the near future at Stormont
so that we can get back to passing legislation on our own terms. Although after more than
1000 days without a working government and with the state of politics right now, I don’t
think many people are holding their breath out for that’, says Naomi Clarke.
This latest failure to use the powers of devolution will have seen ever more people in
Northern Ireland asking their biggest political question, ‘What is the point of Stormont?’
Image by luca.sartoni via Creative Commons
