Review: Candlelight Concert
By Anna Pile
Aglow with warm light, St. Oswald’s Church looked enchanting: the stage framed by an array of candles that both flattered its 12th-century architecture and created the perfect atmosphere for Aidan’s College Theatre’s Candlelight Concert. Constructed around musical theatre songs that explored love in its many forms – hopeful, desperate, gentle, or despairing – the evening offered a genuine and heartfelt emotional journey.
From The Sound of Music to Dear Evan Hansen, the setlist travelled through eras and genres with an ease that felt curated through immaculate casting. Similar concerts and showcases can often fall into a particular trap: to pair performers with songs they can sing, but don’t fully exhibit their talent. Candlelight Concert largely avoided this, as the majority of the songs felt tailor-made for their singers. That achievement became all the more impressive when I was later informed that many of the songs that fit this prior description were recast less than a week before the concert as one performer had to pull out – a credit to not only to the creative team’s judgement, but to a cast who smoothly adapted and continued to perform assuredly.
The cast strode across the stage dressed either in dashing suits or stunning dresses – a cohesive sea of black. ‘Somebody to Love’ (Glee) was electrifying: Imi Myatt’s riffs were gorgeously controlled and Damola Amusa’s high harmonies were impressive, and Caitlyn Leung finished the number with one of the highest – yet healthiest – notes I’ve heard in Durham. Better yet, it wasn’t a one-off. Leung continued to amaze for the remainder of the night, those soaring notes sounding remarkably weightless as they filled the church without a hint of strain.
Director Abi Barker must be commended for recognising all the unique possibilities within the church – and using each and every one of them
One of the most delightful moments was rooted in the staging. As Leung exited, she pointed up towards the opposite end of the church, and my attention snapped up to the balcony: Jamie Duncan stood above us, beginning a beautiful rendition of ‘I Will Go the Distance’ (Hercules) with a tone uncannily similar to Roger Bart’s original recording. Duncan took advantage of the church’s scale, subsequently striding down the aisle towards the stage as if the entire building was a set. That thoughtful use of the space continued, with the cast later singing ‘Seasons of Love’ (Rent) along the outer aisles, directly to the audience, making it a much more communal atmosphere. Director Abi Barker must be commended for recognising all the unique possibilities within the church – and using each and every one of them.
Myatt later returned as Delores in ‘Fabulous Baby’ (Sister Act), commanding the stage with a strong presence and sparkling characterization in her vocals. Expression failed to fully reach the face at times, but the performance remained a joy to watch. This was further lifted through the infectious energy of the backing dancers behind her, performing simple, effective movements (directed by Amelie Marshall-Cawley) that breathed extra life onto stage and, despite some clear moments of confusion, were executed relatively well. ‘My Man’ (Funny Girl), meanwhile, was a faultless pairing for Clara Suss-Francksen. Her rich, classical vocal quality – matched with particularly gripping expressions – captured the audience’s eyes. Suss-Francksen (alongside Ellie Kinch) also deserves credit for the exquisite harmonies and general vocal cohesion as the musical directors.
Another example of a perfect pair of performer and song came through Harry Easton’s Orpheus in ‘All I’ve Ever Known’ (Hadestown). In only a few minutes, Easton immediately captured the role’s complexity, his vocals undeniably captivating. His chemistry with Samantha Sinilong’s Euridice was palpable, and her portrayal was brimming with longing – emotion steadied and enhanced through beautifully controlled singing.
O’Donnell poured heart into each word; his deep yearning, underscored by a gorgeous vibrato, stunned the hall
Among the evening’s standout solos was Jake O’Donnell’s rendition of ‘Maria’ (West Side Story). O’Donnell poured heart into each word; his deep yearning, underscored by a gorgeous vibrato, stunned the hall. Earlier, that same resonant tone had been paired ingeniously with Amusa’s higher register in a popular arrangement combining ‘The Story of Tonight’ (Hamilton) and ‘You Will be Found’ (Dear Evan Hansen), with stellar harmonies that made the most of both voices and sounded genuinely moving. James Butler also demonstrated an impressive upper range, joining Amusa for ‘Happy Days are here Again/Get Happy’ (Glee) – seemingly in the original key, no small feat for a number once performed by Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande.
The main structural issue of the evening lay in the distribution of stage time. Whether this was due to last-minute cast changes or the shape of the set-list, some performers felt disproportionately featured – particularly Butler – while others, such as Cyril Chan, appeared underused. This was disappointing, as Chan provided a dependable backbone across several numbers: a strong resounding lower harmony in ‘Requiem’ (Dear Evan Hansen) and ‘Light’ (Next to Normal), as well as detailed characterisation and clear diction as Hermes in ‘Wait for Me’ (Hadestown), but this sentiment was largely felt because of his mic not working.
With this in mind, the major issue of the concert was technical. A lack of functional microphones hit many of the male cast particularly hard, with some mics too quiet or not working at all. At the other extreme, other mics were turned so high that ensemble numbers were unintentionally transformed into solos, or peaked into feedback piercing enough to steal away the audience’s attention. It was a frustrating watch, with extremely talented performers constantly put against technological obstacles, and the quality of many numbers suffered because of it.
Dixon’s performance as Elle Woods was refreshingly natural: the loss of hope was visible in every choice she made, and her voice was effortlessly angelic
There were also isolated moments where the staging didn’t quite align with a song’s intent. The clearest example came in ‘Legally Blonde’ (Legally Blonde), the final image of which was Duncan’s arms wrapped around Lizzie Dixon, effectively forcing the song into a romantic conclusion. In the original musical the scene ends poignantly with the two characters separated by a door, their love unresolved; it’s a confession of love, but not one that is reciprocated by the final notes. Here, the direction felt slightly blurred. With that said, Dixon’s performance as Elle Woods was refreshingly natural: the loss of hope was visible in every choice she made, and her voice was effortlessly angelic. Despite their movements, the two performers still provided the tender heartbreak the song elicited through their pointed expressions.
Leaving the church, one thing was certain: the cast of Candlelight Concert was extraordinarily talented, and earned every second of the considerable applause they received. The song choices were inspired, the use of St. Oswald’s Church was imaginative, and despite some questionable directional decisions and major technical issues, everyone involved stayed resilient – providing remarkable vocals right through to the end.
Candlelight Concert was performed at St. Oswald’s Church on Saturday 13th June, 2026.
Image: Aidan’s College Theatre via @act.aidanstheatre on Instagram.

