Purpose in Politics
By Charlie Oliver
Abstracts rule modern politics. Not to say they aren’t useful; values such as liberty, nation, and justice serve to guide our actions. Directing public policy towards these ambiguous ideals and distracting from lacklustre responses is, however, a mistake. Recent governments have forgotten that these values must serve a greater goal than themselves; that of good government and the welfare of our citizens. Expecting the country to survive while we paste over problems with vague slogans will lead to our downfall – we have to change the incentives of our decision making.
We are guided by meaningless mantras – ‘strong and stable’, ‘real change, now’ – and focus on political expediency over what is pressing to the circumstances. Year after year we allow huge increases in the deficit for ideological tax cuts and endless foreign wars, but if we want to invest in the future then suddenly the economy will self-destruct. Aimless politicians are confusing themselves – we’re following the neo-liberal/neo-conservative consensus off a cliff.
We are guided by meaningless mantras and focus on political expediency over more pressing concerns
Needlessly dividing society into all number of identity groups, and instigating meaningless wars over which is most oppressed, condemns the Left to the same fate. Grandiose virtue signalling has led them to abandon their true purpose – the voice of those deserted by the cold, relentless scythe of capitalist meritocracy.
Meanwhile, actual politics is left behind. Education, healthcare, and policing are used by both sides as political footballs – talk of their practical problems is replaced by larger, often unrelated, discussions of the ‘strength of the economy’ or ‘fairness’. Partisan bickering engulfs legislative debates. You would think from our politicians that the only way to solve the ecological crisis was either to continue the myth of everlasting growth, moving to new technologies when the market provides them, or to submit to the self-imposed misery of an egalitarian nightmare. Policy makers cannot separate solutions from their own worldviews; nuance is lost on these people.
This path is creating a justified resentment amongst those who have not benefited from the status-quo ideology of our times. Manufacturing has declined, capital has centralised in big cities, and automation threatens the elimination of routine work. In the communities hardest hit by this, there is little social cohesion or faith in authority; the backbone of civilisation. As the problems spread, so will this resentment. Without fundamentally changing what politics is about, we risk collapsing our society.
Education, healthcare and policing are used by both sides as political footballs
Reponses to Covid-19 have shown this task is not impossible. Our reaction to the coronavirus so far has been deeply focused on the issue, listening to experts and then acting on that advice. Rishi Sunak (who is doing a sterling job) can pull £350 billion out of a hat for this problem; listening to previous Chancellors tells us that this money does not exist. Yet the economic repercussions of the virus will come not from increased government spending, but from drastically reducing demand in the economy through the lockdown (something not required of solutions for job market, policing, or environmental issues). Shelter for the homeless is now guaranteed for the foreseeable future – what was missing before was not money, but political will.
This new politics, with the goal of the welfare of society, fundamentally shakes up our decision-making incentives by putting humanity first. Experts, and those intimately involved with problems, should take priority over minsters and their ever-obstructive army of bureaucrats. Welfare will require nuanced, local solutions – the structure of decision making will have to change. Although this will seem strange, I think we’ll grow to like it. Really, it’s not too far-fetched to suggest that government should work for citizens and not political expediency. The politics of practical, thoughtful, and welfare-centric policy, that of Rory Stewart and Andrew Yang, is gaining ground – we need to embrace it before it is too late.
Image: Mariko via Flickr
