Student campaigns work – but Common Rooms must lead them.
Leo Harris
Epiphany term has seen Durham’s biggest student campaign in recent years — that of Re-Open Nominations (RON) in the Students’ Union Officer and Trustee elections. A perfect example of how College Common Rooms influence opinion. But more than this, how Common Rooms need more access to policymaking in our University. The RON campaign proved the effectiveness of Common Rooms coming together: communicating to discuss the SU’s electoral processes; to address the funding imbalance of the SU vs. Common Rooms; and to bring to the forefront a question that nearly all my members bring to me when they discuss the SU – ‘but what does it actually do?’
The SU has become too focused on the fringe issues
Now, I don’t deny that the SU cares and is hard-working — because it is. Just like all student leaders in Durham do their best for their students. But my fundamental issue with the SU is that it has become too inward-looking and focused on the fringe issues. That’s why I backed the RON campaign, and that was a campaign that worked. We now know that 58% of first preference votes in the elections went to RON – an unprecedented, near super-majority of unhappy students.
So, what does this show? For me, it boils down to a simple point: students recognising the imbalance of influence that currently make campaigns ineffective. Yes, 27 undergraduate and graduate Common Rooms can create a lot of noise. But still, that’s 28 organisations and 27 leaders who have the closest ear to the ground with our students. Literally – we eat, live and breathe in colleges. We’re apolitical organisations that reach a broad church of student opinion. Common Rooms only take stances on issues if these affect the majority of our students. The greatest good for the greatest number – not a vocal minority.
JCR Presidents have the time and remit to invest in university-wide issues — something we’ve all done throughout this year. And yet, despite all this, the SU gets significantly more contact-time with University leaders. Common Room heads get a well-used, two-hour monthly meeting with Jeremy Cook, the Pro Vice-Chancellor for Colleges and Student Experience. Yet the University has 44 committees with student representation: Common Rooms sit on 5; the SU on at least 23.
Our students know who we are; students recognise Common Rooms as their voice
The SU has led many important student campaigns to influence policy – namely RippedOff. But these sit in the background. They need more traction and effective facilitation. In the case of RippedOff, success has come from Common Rooms conducting independent campaigns –like St Aidan’s, or Cuth’s. It only took Common Room leaders a long weekend to bring the RON campaign to the forefront of student discussion. Why? Because our students know who we are. We can take issues to small, close-knit communities. And leaders within Common Rooms represent an unrivalled power in numbers – 54 people helped lead the campaign. And RON worked.
The University recognised the dissatisfaction among students with its SU representatives and knows something must be done. The Pro Vice-Chancellor has reached out to address the imbalances in finances and representation; not to hush Common Rooms, or ‘tell-off’ the SU – but to find a better approach for both parties. Mediation is due to take place when a suitable, post-coronavirus opportunity allows. The agenda is set. The campaign — a success. 58% of first-preference RON votes prove that students recognise Common Rooms as their voice. But now this needs institutionalising further. Only once Common Rooms are placed more at the heart of representation can students really influence university policymaking.
Image: Durham Student’s Union via Durham University
