PSG break their UCL duck, but is it really a ‘win for football’?
By Ben Pawlowski
It was brilliant. It was electric. It was brutal. In truth, all manner of superlative could have been used to describe Paris Saint-Germain’s magnificent 5-0 demolition of Inter Milan in last month’s UEFA Champions League final. The lucky tens of thousands packed into the Allianz Arena in Munich were treated to an orgy of footballing brilliance, a spectacle of skill, a feast of youthful exuberance and fearlessness. It was one of the great Champions League performances.
Naturally, pundits and commentators were lining up to exalt and laud Luis Enrique’s side. Mark Pougatch described the rout as a ‘humiliation’. For Julien Laurens, PSG were ‘unplayable’. Writing in The Times, Martin Samuel labelled PSG as ‘captivating’, but without the ‘galactico glitter’ of yesteryear. Some went further. Famously prone to engaging in hyperbole and exaggeration, TNT Sports pundit Rio Ferdinand called PSG’s victory ‘a win for football’. For him, this was what the beautiful game was all about.
To be fair to Rio – departing TNT Sports this year – he has a point. To watch Desiré Doué, Ousmane Dembele and Khvicha Kvaratskhelia with a football at their feet is to watch football of the highest order. In an all-too-welcome antidote to the modern game’s displeasing addiction to wrangling all trace of creativity out of its best players, PSG’s attacking trio were given licence to do whatever they wanted. And they did just that, playing with an expressiveness, vision and artistry that proved far too much for Inter’s aging defence.
To be fair to Rio – departing TNT Sports this year – he has a point. To watch Desiré Doué, Ousmane Dembele and Khvicha Kvaratskhelia with a football at their feet is to watch football of the highest order
Elsewhere, to watch Vitinha prowl around the pitch was to see someone at the very peak of their powers, demonstrating finesse, strength and mesmerising intelligence. Nuno Mendes has cemented himself as the best left-back in the world. Gianluigi Donnarumma has been imperious on the European battle front. On the sidelines, the sight of PSG fans unveiling a tifo of Enrique’s daughter, Xana, who died of cancer in 2019 aged nine, brought a lump to millions of throats.
But this is also exactly what the beautiful game should not be about. To indulge in the magnificence of this young PSG side is also to acquiesce in the grey, mirky waters of their ownership. To praise the Parisians as the pinnacle of modern football is to give in to the sportswashing project that belies the billions of euros of investment pumped into the club.
After all, this was no underdog tale, no story of plucky perseverance or dogged determination. This was the ultimate culmination of a 14-year-long project, authored by an autocratic nation state – PSG’s majority owners are Qatar Sports Investments (QSI), a subsidiary of the Qatari sovereign wealth fund. In the past two seasons, they have spent €694 million on new players, a figure only eclipsed by Chelsea. In a clear case of dubious sponsorship dealings, Qatar Airways are emblazoned on the front of their shirts.
Rather than being the medicine modern football needs, PSG’s story is reflective of its own flaws. With victory in Munich, PSG followed in the footsteps of Manchester City in 2022/23 by becoming yet another club owned by a nation state to have won a treble, symptomatic of the dominance teams can achieve when backed by the financial firepower of an entire country willing to bend rules and dig deep into their pockets. Just like the 2022 World Cup, the win is a coup for a Qatari regime eager to clean up its image amid widespread allegations of terrible human rights abuses and appalling treatment of migrant workers.
Rather than being the medicine modern football needs, PSG’s story is reflective of its own flaws
In some ways, many supporters could be forgiven for thinking that football has turned a welcome corner. Mercurial young talents like Doue or Barcelona’s Lamine Yamal feel like a breath of fresh air, a relief from the monotony of overbearing tactical systems. After a brief lull as the careers of Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo slowly come to an end, it feels as if football finally has its new poster boys.
Maybe things are changing on the pitch. But the reality is somewhat different off it. After all, this is the first summer of the inaugural revamped Club World Cup, a grotesque display of football’s very worst excesses with sky-high ticket prices, a bizarre format, an eye-watering prize fund and an excessive burden on a football calendar already on the brink of collapse. Likewise, the nauseating sight of Gianni Infantino cuddling up to President Trump or missing key FIFA meetings to woo leaders in the Middle East is a stark reminder that the structures of football governance have scarcely improved since the days of Sepp Blatter and co.
At risk of sounding like a footballing version of Ebenezer Scrooge, this does not mean we should not enjoy PSG’s victory or praise the effortless brilliance of their young squad. But there is always a caveat. That should never ever be forgotten. If it is, then the sportswashing project triumphs. And in its footsteps many more will thus follow.
Image: Like tears in rain via Wikimedia Commons

