Prisoners being released by accident: The justice system in turmoil?
By Jess Dowse
At Prime Minister’s Questions on the 5th of November, the Deputy Prime Minister and Justice Secretary David Lammy came under fire, facing pressure to take accountability following his handling of the accidental release of two inmates from HMP Wandsworth. In the previous 12 months, the accidental release of prisoners before they have served their time has increased by 128%, from 115 to 262 incidents.
Firstly, let’s take a look at what actually happened in these pugnacious PMQs. A visibly frustrated Lammy was repeatedly questioned by the Shadow Defence Secretary, James Cartlidge, whether he knew of any further wrongful releases following that of Kebatu from HMP Chelmsford. He refused to answer, a decision which was met with strong criticism after it emerged during the questioning that Brahim Kaddour-Cherif, a 24-year-old Algerian national, was mistakenly released from HMP Wandsworth in south London on 29 October. This occurred from the same prison as the wrongful release of fraudster William Smith, but only the latter has been recaptured at the time of writing. Lammy was reportedly informed overnight about this, leading debate to be had as to whether he was deliberately not answering questions addressed to him, or whether he did not wish to speak without having a comprehensive understanding of the matter, weighing up which information to publicly release, according to Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy.
I’n the previous 12 months, the accidental release of prisoners before they have served their time has increased by 128%, from 115 to 262 incidents’
More broadly, there seems to be a discrepancy between the current image portrayed by Lammy of a prison system intending to implement ‘the toughest checks we have ever had’ and the continuous accidental releases occurring, 91 between April and October this year to be exact. In fact, the prison association itself seems to deem accidental release of prisoners as something which is impossible to completely eradicate without significant change. The Prison Governor’s Association stated that the conditions to “reduce this figure (0.5%) to zero simply do not exist”, further commenting that it ‘’feels disingenuous to see politicians attempt to extract political gain from a prison system in crisis.’’
So why then is there this sentiment of helplessness? And what is the reason for the prison system being continually under strain under multiple governments? A new Justice Committee report may provide some insight to this. Severe overcrowding, including multiple inmates in a single cell, chronic staff shortages and worsening conditions are some of the reasons responsible for an 80% reoffending rate, in stark opposition to the primary goal of rehabilitation. Staff morale is currently at a very low level, with 13% of the prison force having left in a single year-long period. Perhaps most significantly, is the decrease in funding. According to the Institute for Fiscal Studies, day-to-day spending by the Justice Department is almost 6% lower in real terms than in 2010, despite rising prison populations and increasingly complex operational demands.
”Much of the political response has been centred around calls for accountability, especially from the Conservative party”
Whilst the Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer, has expressed his anger and frustration surrounding this issue, vowing that change will happen, much of the political response has been centred around calls for accountability, especially from the Conservative party. Cartlidge for instance called for an investigation into whether the justice secretary had broken the ministerial code by failing to be ‘transparent’. Lammy has in return pointed to the long-lasting and ongoing nature of this problem, highlighting that 800 errors occurred under the last government.
It is clear however, that underneath the noise of the constant shifting of blame between politicians there is a prison system drowning and strained to record levels, amid claims that prisons are expected to be full again at the start of 2026. Perhaps these high-profile wrong releases and the responses to them will be the catalyst for long lasting systemic change to prevent such things from happening.
Image: The Conservative Party via Wikimedia Commons

