Booker prize 2025 shortlist: The Rest of Our Lives

By Lucy Hickman

At time of writing, the winner of the Booker Prize has yet to be announced; but on Monday the 10th of November the winner will receive £50,000 in prize money. Amongst the six shortlisted books is The Rest of Our Lives by Ben Markovitz, which explores middle-aged masculinity and mortality through a sincere, if sometimes frustrating, perspective.

The novel’s narrator is 55-year-old Tom Lawyard, a father dropping his daughter off at college. This moment represents a crossroads in his life, as after his wife’s infidelity twelve years ago, he made a promise to himself that he would leave once both his children had gone to college. Indeed, he confesses to the reader at the beginning of the novel: ‘when our son was 12 years old, my wife had an affair…’ establishing the narrator’s distinct tone of detached sincerity. The quiet tension that pervades the novel hinges on this premise: will Tom go through with his promise and leave the marriage? The narrator reflects on his marriage though in an unsentimental voice: ‘what we obviously had, even when things smoothed over, was a C-minus marriage, which makes it pretty hard to score much higher than a B overall on the rest of your life.’ The novel raises questions about how we define ourselves; is your life defined by your marriage, what becomes of your life after marriage and kids?

The Rest of Our Lives […] explores middle-aged masculinity and mortality through a sincere, if sometimes frustrating, perspective

The novel is structured around various motifs: it is primarily presented to us as a classic American road trip, beginning with Tom’s journey to Pittsburgh to take his daughter to college, and then continuing as he keeps driving, visiting his brother, an old girlfriend, a college friend and then his son. But it is also structured around illness: there are references to sickness throughout (Tom is warned to see a doctor by his family and the people he visits on his journey) which culminate at the end of the novel. This creates a sense of unease and discomfort but also raises questions of mortality and the finite nature of time. Thirdly, basketball is a recurring motif: it is a constant source of metaphors, a means by which the narrator seems to relate to the world, and how he connects the past and present.

A lack of resolution is at the heart of this novel as all of these narrative strands remain incomplete and open-ended. The narrator’s journey repeatedly evades satisfying endings and goodbyes instead, we are left with the denial of intimacy and romance. This is perhaps epitomised by the woman Tom and his brother meet at the bar, who they briefly wait outside for, before leaving when she doesn’t arrive. Tom’s initial promise to leave his wife, arguably his most significant and heroic action in the book, is also repeatedly left unresolved, as he tells other characters in the book: ‘I may have left Amy.’ Moreover, he tells the reader of his earlier ambitions to write a book about basketball. He initially seems to be following this through as he stops off at various basketball courts along his journey. After one of the games, he poses for a picture with the other players reflecting that: ‘sometimes, sitting in the hospital chair, I think about that afternoon, and tell myself, maybe again’. The ‘maybe’ means the reader is left overwhelmingly uncertain: Tom’s ambition, just like his resolve to leave his wife, is neither thwarted nor fulfilled.

The narrator’s refusal to give any sense of resolution can be frustrating and for me left some elements of the novel feeling underdeveloped. Questions of political correctness in academia are brought to the forefront, as we are told Tom has been put on leave at work after students complained about the politics of his law class. Ultimately, it felt these issues were only explored on a surface level with Tom refusing to express any kind of definitive opinion on them. Likewise, the portrayal of some of the characters in the novel felt a bit one-note, particularly Tom’s wife, who is never granted much emotional depth beyond complaining.

The narrator’s journey repeatedly evades satisfying endings and goodbyes instead, we are left with the denial of intimacy and romance

The moments in which the novel explores father-child relationships felt the most sincere and moving to me. The novel presents a quiet struggle between generations, which largely hinges on the fraught nature of communication. The narrator describes his daughter as ‘almost physically reminding herself to be interested in someone else’s life’. Tom also struggles to communicate with his son, as he states matter-of-factly that ‘Michael had become one of those young people who decides that contact with their family is not a source of happiness, so you have to limit it to unavoidable occasions’. But the narrator never asks for our sympathy, he summarises: ‘these things happen – families end up a certain way’. Ultimately, it is this unheroic, understated voice which makes for such an endearing protagonist, and one that feels universal.

Image Credit: Yoann Galiotto (Courtesy of Wiki Media Commons)