Russian jets encroach on NATO airspace: testing the water?
By Georgia Evans
The North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) has been in and out of the news lately, mostly regarding funding and relations with the US. It was quite unexpected to receive the news notification that Russia had flown three MiG-31 fighter jets into Estonian airspace for a total of 12 minutes over the Gulf of Finland.
Estonia is one of the Baltic states, bordering Russia, and, until August 1991, was occupied by Russia, creating a fraught and tense history between the two nations. Following Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine, there was a surge of concern in national security, but tensions had eased lately, with NATO providing something of a security blanket.
However, on the 20th of September, Estonia had to trigger Article 4 of the treaty, making it the second country in September to do so, as Poland had done so just 10 days prior, when Russian drones had entered its airspace. Article 4 of the Nato treaty formally begins urgent discussions with the 32 members. Italy, Finland and Sweden all quickly deployed jets to increase security on the eastern border, which highlights the value of such an alliance.
On the 20th of September, Estonia has to trigger Article 4 of the treaty, making it the second country in September to do so
The most well-known part of the NATO alliance is Article 5, which is the concept that an attack on one is an attack on all. Article 4 precedes this and is indicative of escalating tensions, especially considering that two other NATO members (Poland and Romania) also reported Russian drones breaching their airspace.
Furthermore, Germany’s Munich airport closed on 2 October following reports of drones. In August, Lithuania reported that two Russian military drones launched from Belarus crashed into its territory, which resulted in the government passing legislation allowing unmanned drones to be shot down. These incidents demonstrate a greater trend of insecurity caused by Russian aggression, insecurity that is exacerbated by proximity to the Russian border.
The inherent conception of NATO reflects the historic tensions between Russia and the West, created in 1949 by the United States, intrinsically linked to the Cold War. Six years later came the Warsaw Pact, which was a direct response to the formal alliance of the West. When considering this context, it is not surprising that the US has historically been the largest financier of NATO; however, despite claims made by President Trump, it only provides 1/6 of funding.
The US has historically been the largest financier of NATO; however, despite claims made by President Trump, it only provides 1/6 of funding
There is also a requirement for European members to spend at least 2% of their GDP (gross domestic product) on defence. In fact, NATO estimates for 2024 saw Poland as the top spender, at 4.1%, up by 0.2% from the previous year, and Estonia second at 3.4%, joint with the US. This demonstrates the differing threats felt by the nations and undermines the American argument that their spending is unreasonable in comparison to that of European states.
In the process of writing this article, there have been constant developments, highlighting the nature of Russia’s evolving attitude towards international relations. This can be demonstrated through the fact that the UK has sent military support to Belgium after a number of suspected Russian drones that came into their airspace, forcing Brussels Airport to temporarily close on Thursday 6 November.
These cases all highlight a worrying change in Russian power, as there appears to be an increasing willingness from Russia to violate the airspace of NATO members; a sentiment the Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has echoed, warning that Russia is testing the strength of the alliance, which could potentially have significant ramifications for the future of Europe, as NATO is struggling to agree on how best to respond to these threats, especially as the tone could set a precedent for future dealings with a seemingly voracious Russia.
Image: Fedor Leukhin via Wikimedia Commons

