Prime Minister Miliband?
Anybody wishing to gain greater insight into the inner workings of the Labour Party under Ed Miliband would be well advised to read Tim Bale’s excellent book, ‘Five Year Mission’, which documents Miliband’s rise from accidental party leader to Prime Minister in waiting. In ten days time it could be consigned to the bookshelves of political history. Alternatively, if the polls are to be believed, it will become compulsory reading in order to understand how the next Prime Minister intends to govern.
Miliband’s transformation during the past few weeks has been nothing short of extraordinary. He has utterly dispelled the Tory myth that he is weird and stupid, reaching out to voters on the campaign trail with an enthusiasm and intelligence that has eluded his opponents. Perhaps even more impressively, Miliband has won the argument within his own party. Labour already faces accusations from other left-wing parties that it has gravitated too far away from its traditional roots. Had Miliband moved it further to the centre still, as many moderates advocated, accusations that Labour was simply ‘Tory-lite’ would have been hard to disprove.
Indeed, Labour is in a position to reclaim power after just five years in the wilderness of opposition precisely because it has offered a persuasive alternative. Numerous though the current government’s faults may be, it can claim success inasmuch as it has presided over the creation of two million jobs, a fall in crime and a rise in under-privileged young people heading to university. Yet Miliband has resorted to the classic Ronald Reagan line of asking voters whether they are better off now than they were before, and has convinced large swathes of the electorate that the answer to that question is no.
For all that Miliband is often sketchy on the detail, offering a vision that is both inoffensively vague to keep radical wings of his party happy, and clear enough to win support from the much-coveted ‘ordinary’ hard-working person, there is a pronounced difference between his party and David Cameron’s. Whereas Labour campaigns against a bedroom tax that disproportionately affects the poorest and most vulnerable, the Conservatives continue to pursue damaging cuts to public services and tax breaks for the wealthiest. When put in such terms, it is no wonder that Miliband is on course for victory.
However, just as when he became Labour Party leader five years ago, it is unlikely to be a clear-cut triumph. Having owed his position as leader of the opposition to trade union support, much to the consternation of those senior shadow cabinet ministers who voted for his brother, Miliband will inevitably need the support of a smaller party in order to form a functioning government. Should the Liberal Democrats manage to avoid the apocalyptic collapse predicted by many, Nick Clegg’s party may be kingmakers for the second successive election. Reuniting the progressive wings of British politics is a comforting idea to Miliband as he plots his path ahead, but looks a mathematical impossibility given the projected decimation of Lib Dem MPs. At the time of writing, the two parties are set to fall short of the 300 mark between them.
A more likely scenario is that Miliband will have to negotiate with the Scottish National Party. Although he has been unequivocal in saying that Labour will not countenance a formal coalition with the SNP or a vote-by-vote arrangement, there will need to be a reassessment of this no-compromise position should their combined representation in the House of Commons reach 326. The constitutional crisis that such an arrangement would trigger has been overblown, even if it is a far from ideal situation to have a party whose existence is premised on the break-up of the United Kingdom playing such a significant role in Westminster politics. Labour has committed to a constitutional convention should it return to power, which would go some way to reassuring English voters that their MPs will have a degree of autonomy over English-only issues.
Sensing that the election is slipping away from them, the Tories have attempted to warn against a Labour-SNP deal for two reasons. Firstly, it may convince undecided voters to vote Tory. Secondly, it means that they can immediately denounce the next government as illegitimate, spending the next five years complaining about the democratic deficit that has led the second biggest party in the House of Commons to steal power on the basis of support from a party with no mandate in England.
Once Miliband makes it over the line, should he do so, he will be less concerned about how legitimate his government is perceived to be, and more focused on implementing his plan for Britain. Much of what he offers is simply a reversal of measures implemented by the coalition. The bedroom tax would be scrapped and the 50p top rate of tax re-introduced, moves that will most certainly divide opinion, but mean he will be judged by what he does as Prime Minister, rather than by how he got the job in the first place.
The outcome is now out of Miliband’s hands. Barring the possibilities of a late Tory revival coupled with an incumbency swing in their favour, which is by no means out of the question given the pertinent historical precedent of 1992, he will be the next Prime Minister. By emphasising the perils of a Labour-SNP alliance, the Tories are trying to engineer a situation where Miliband is the de facto loser even if he wins. Given the dismally low base from which he started, it is tempting to think that even being in contention at this late stage represents a victory of sorts. That, though, is an unacceptably defeatist mindset, because the reality is this: Miliband’s five-year mission will only be accomplished if he carries it forward in government.
Photograph: EdMiliband, Flickr

