Primary school children are missing out
By Meg Wishart
Last week, primary school pupils across Scotland returned to their “new normal”: virtual school. No playground games, golden time or lunches with friends. All of the fun parts about school have been stripped away — for the second time. It’s yet another confusing and difficult adjustment for all, including my eight-year-old sister. But not for the reason you might expect.
Microsoft Teams, one of the main online learning platforms, was down for many pupils last week. During her lunchtime briefing, Nicola Sturgeon reassured anxious parents and children up and down the country, that the problem was being fixed. Yet even when Teams has been fully functioning, many schools have failed to take advantage of some of its features, like the ability to live-stream lessons. Despite almost two weeks of online learning, my sister has only had a couple of live classes. Compared to many, this is millions. Despite John Swinney (Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills) highlighting the importance of a balance of ‘live learning and independent activity’, live-lessons are not being offered to all. Another disparity to add to the long list.
I can’t remember all of the facts I learned for exams
Instead of adopting a uniform approach, which Swinney labelled as ‘counterproductive’, decisions surrounding online learning have been left to individual schools and teachers. This has faced considerable backlash from groups like the ‘50/50 In-School Campaign’, who advocate for minimum standards in terms of ‘real teacher and class contact as well as interactive online lessons.’ Online learning presents innumerable challenges. But even the ability to learn online is nothing short of a privilege. So far, during the pandemic, the Scottish Government has distributed 50,000 devices. This is a step in the right direction; it hasn’t been a solution. Many children still don’t have access to a device, let alone a device of their own.
At the end of her first day of virtual school, my sister reminded me of something I had forgotten about. Or, perhaps more accurately, someone: my eight-year-old self. The one that, probably just like you, sat cross-legged on the itchy primary school carpet; the one who completely idolised her teacher and wanted to be just like her when she grew up.
Teachers have the power to change the way these children see themselves
We’ve all read about the impact of repeat lockdowns on education: plummeting literacy rates and poor exam scores. Whilst this is a part of education, it is an insignificant part at that. I can’t remember all of the facts I learned for exams. Thanks to my sister, I now remember something far more important than any of this: what it felt like to be inspired on a daily basis, to have a role model, to want to work hard to earn a gold star. Forgetting your times-tables is one thing. The absence of eight-year-olds — just like my sister — feeling inspired every time they sit cross-legged, is another.
Teachers aren’t given enough credit. They are truly transformative. Every day, they have the power to inspire a classroom full of eager faces — who all have different backgrounds and home environments. For many children, their classroom is the only safe space in their world. When teaching is face-to-face, teachers notice when these children need support. Teachers have the power to change the way these children see themselves, their futures and their dreams. I wholeheartedly doubt this can be achieved over Microsoft Teams.
My sister is one of the lucky ones. She has everything she needs to make the most of online learning: technology and a supportive home environment. Even with all of this, she’s struggling to keep focused and motivated. She misses getting to see her teacher in person; raising her hand to ask her questions. I can’t help but think of the children who would just love to see their teacher’s fuzzy face on Microsoft Teams.
Image: Juraj Varga from Pixabay

