Do we value freedom less after the pandemic?

By Tom McNeile

The United Kingdom among other western democracies prides itself on being a beacon of freedom where people are able to live their lives with minimal restrictions. Throughout the Covid-19 outbreak in the United Kingdom, the government has tried to ensure that the population is kept as safe as possible without imposing measures on the public that might appear overly draconian. This method has relied heavily upon the conscious choice of individuals to enforce social distancing and self-isolation rules.

Unfortunately, this has not proven to be a constructive method of dealing with the virus and stricter regulations have had to be brought in at a later stage. These measures were arguably not well-enforced and implemented too late to prevent significant loss of life with the total number of Covid-19 related deaths now over 70,000.

Throughout the Covid-19 pandemic, we have had limitations placed on many aspects of our lives. From travelling around the country to meeting with friends, these are things that we might have taken for granted as a privilege of living in a free country. The introduction of a national lockdown almost certainly saved countless lives but in exchange for a proportion of our freedom, questioning where the line should be drawn with the current restrictions.

It is undoubtable that the United Kingdom still views freedom as an integral value within society

South Korea has emerged from this pandemic as one of the few success stories having permitted the tracking of civilians and emergency alerts that provided details about people infected with the virus. This allowed a more definitive diagnosis of the virus and meant that people could be more certain of whether they were a transmission risk. Furthermore, a cohort of intelligence officers was recruited to monitor the compliance of members of the public using technology such as credit card transactions and closed-circuit CCTV footage. Admittedly this does seem on the surface to be a significant infringement of privacy, but it is undeniable that members of the public in South Korea are experiencing greater freedom than in the UK at this time as a result of laws such as these.

South Korea’s response to the pandemic has shown that certain laws that initially appear to infringe on one’s liberty, have actually allowed people to return to work and continue with their lives in a way that cannot happen in the UK as we find ourselves in yet another lockdown. It is undoubtable that the United Kingdom still views freedom as an integral value within society, but the implementation of repeated lockdowns during the Covid-19 pandemic has highlighted the fact that constraints on freedom already exist in modern societies. If we were to manage restrictions in a different way it may actually end up providing us with greater emancipation as seen in South Korea.

Laws have always constantly changed in order to serve the best interests of the public

Societies have been built up over time by the addition and removal of various new rules that aim to improve the system. In 1752, the passing into law for “better preventing the horrid crime of murder” was imposed on the population of England. This was not done to reduce their freedom but to allow people to live in a society where they can carry out daily activities with a greatly reduced risk of being killed.

It seems humorous to look back on the introduction of this law and try and imagine people protesting this infringement of their liberty and yet this event has repeated itself throughout history and to produce the society that we live in. Laws have always constantly changed in order to serve the best interests of the public and the introduction of laws that require concessions to our privacy may be a viable route to the creation of a society with greater freedom.

Image: Daniel Roberts from Pixabay