The crucial differences between the US Capitol and Hong Kong’s protests
By Bernard Wun
Since 6 January, Beijing mouthpieces like Global Times have drawn comparisons between American protestors breaching the Capitol and Hong Kong protestors storming the Legislative Council (LegCo) Complex on 1 July 2019. They criticize American politicians for adopting a double standard by condemning the American protestors while supporting those in Hong Kong.
Pro-Beijing media also praise the Hong Kong police, which have been criticized worldwide for their severe brutalities since 2019, for restraining themselves when protestors stormed the LegCo Complex, unlike American police who shot a female protestor. I never bother responding to Beijing mouthpieces, but after seeing Will Ripley, a CNN international correspondent, mislead the public by drawing the same illogical comparison, I find it essential to point out the absurdity of the comparison, even though Ripley’s instagram post has already been deleted.
It is essential to point out the absurdity of the comparison
Before explaining why the comparison is illogical, I shall provide an overview of what had happened before the LegCo Complex was stormed. The Hong Kong government proposed an extradition bill allowing its residents to be extradited to mainland China, whose judicial system is not trusted. On 16 June 2019, two million protestors who were against the bill marched peacefully.
Nonetheless, the government only ‘temporarily suspended’ the bill but refused to have it withdrawn. Once the bill is put to vote in the LegCo, it would undoubtedly pass because the LegCo is always dominated by pro-Beijing lawmakers owing to a huge flaw in its electoral system. Therefore, on 1 July, after another rally with more than half a million protestors marching peacefully, some protestors stormed the LegCo Complex to show that the LegCo was a symbol of authoritarianism and did not represent Hongkongers.
The storming of the Capitol and that of the LegCo are incomparable owing to three reasons. First, Hong Kong’s legislative body’s electoral system is totally different from the US’s. In Hong Kong, half of the members of the LegCo are elected not through direct elections, but only by very few eligible voters or legal entities. Thus, the LegCo is always dominated by pro-Beijing politicians and hence simply rubber-stamps almost every bill proposed by the government.
Hong Kong protestors have a much higher level of justification in storming the LegCo Complex
In contrast, the US’s democratic electoral system allows candidates from either party to win the Congressional elections by securing a mandate from voters. Congress can therefore represent voters to a much larger extent. In this sense, Hong Kong protestors have a much higher level of justification in storming the LegCo Complex.
In addition, there is a significant difference in public opinions in the US and Hong Kong. Americans voted for Biden, implying that Trump’s supporters were the minority, whereas an overwhelming majority of the public in Hong Kong were against the extradition bill. As key opinion leader Terry Yeung pointed out, if three million protestors marched in support of the extradition bill before the LegCo Complex was stormed, the two incidents would have been more comparable. Nonetheless, the rally never took place in reality. Therefore, the storming of the LegCo Complex is more justifiable than that of the Capitol in the sense that Hong Kong protestors represented a vast majority of the public while protestors storming the Capitol represented the minority.
Comparing police officers in the two stormings is also preposterous. When pro-Beijing media praised the Hong Kong police for not opening fire on protestors who stormed the LegCo Complex, they neglected the crucial fact that Americans, unlike Hongkongers, have the right to keep and bear arms. Note that I am not defending the shooting of the female protestor at the Capitol. In fact, I believe the incident must be thoroughly investigated.
It is high time journalists examined their opinions before voicing them
I am only arguing that the different reactions of the police in the two incidents are incomparable. Besides, if pro-Beijing media consider refraining from opening fire on protestors praiseworthy, the Hong Kong police are not as praiseworthy as they often describe. This is because there were police officers opening fire on unarmed protestors within an extremely short distance in October and November 2019 respectively, causing extremely severe injuries of the unarmed protestors.
Beijing mouthpieces comparing the two incidents is unsurprising because the absurdity of the comparison is consistent with their other opinions. Nevertheless, it is disappointing to see a correspondent working for such a prominent media company drawing the same illogical comparison simply based on the visual similarity of the two incidents. It is high time journalists examined their opinions, which may strongly influence the public, before voicing them. Media audiences should also remain critical and avoid dogmatically believing in journalists.
Image: Studio Incendo via Creative Commons

