Post-Paris: how will solidarity go?
By James Lindsay
A special service to commemorate the families of the victims and the survivors of the Paris terrorist attacks, which took the lives of over 130 people, has taken place at Notre Dame Cathedral in the French capital. Two days after the horrific tragedy, the world is still reeling from the largest act of terrorism on European soil in over a decade. In the latest development in the unravelling of the events, a French citizen of Algerian descent has been identified as one of the gunmen involved.
France is in three days of mourning amidst widespread displays of solidarity, as the international community pledge their support to the embattled nation. “France’s pain is our pain,” said British Prime Minister, David Cameron.
The bombings on Friday the 13th of November, claimed by Daesh, are particularly outstanding because of the targets chosen by the militants. Owing to the motives behind the shootings, it might have been assumed that government buildings or tourism sites would be attacked; rather it was ordinary, working-class civilians who suffered. They ambushed centres of leisure, restaurants, bars, a rock concert, and a football stadium, underlining that no individual is safe, and there is little national governments can do in response. There was a clear cultural undertone to the choice of targets, too. Daesh has referred to rock concertgoers as “pagans”.
Until further investigation into the bombings, it can plausibly be assumed that the French security services are not to blame. This was not a blunder. Ever since the Charlie Hebdo attacks, France has stepped up security, but it has been a difficult balance to find. Unlike Britain, the most CCTV-surveyed state in Europe, France translates its values of individual liberty into fewer invasive security measures.
There are no possible positives to be drawn from this. The deaths inflict a deep wound on France, and a deeper one on the families directly affected. Inhabitants of all of Western Europe’s major cities feel threatened. Theresa May, Britain’s Home Secretary, said Britons should not be afraid, simply “alert”, but can anyone possibly feel at ease after such an atrocity?
France is particularly vulnerable to such an attack for multiple reasons. The first reason is its borders, which by default, because of France’s commitment to Schengen, are permeable, and thus, practically speaking, indefensible. Any number of guns and terrorists may pass through. The next issue is the marginalisation of immigrants. France has one of the largest Muslim populations in Western Europe, about 7.5%, compared to 5% in Britain, according to a study by the Pew Research Center. Many of these are clustered around Paris, often in segregated housing estates. Prospects in these areas are low and disillusionment is rife. They can become hotbeds for jihad, as young men and women feel disenfranchised and excluded. Indeed, at about 500, France has contributed the largest number of citizens fighting for Daesh in Western Europe.
So what is to be done? It has been ascertained that there were probably three synchronised teams involved in the assault. Unlike the comparatively amateurish air of the Charlie Hebdo shootings, this operation appeared organised and coordinated. It is essential to determine where the bombers came from and how they were financed. It makes a difference whether the attack was planned by IS from the Middle East or whether it was a Daesh-inspired attack by radicalized French Islamists.
The worry with Friday’s bombings, and the reason they are creating so much fear, is that the civilian targets chosen are nearly impossible to defend. The deaths are likely to cause a significant degree of panic. Cameron reiterated that the aim of the militants was “to divide us and destroy our way of life”. World leaders are urging solidarity, yet the extent of this can be doubted.
If anything, this attack has illuminated the limitations of the security forces for everyone to see. Other security measures have to be expected. Should France continue with air strikes? After these attacks the country will await with trepidation for Francois Hollande, the French President, to keep the far-right National Front at bay. Solidarity needs results, and specifically in the Syrian Crisis.
Solidarity means cooperation and compromise and, in the absence of a better plan, Western leaders should join Vladimir Putin in backing the Syrian President, Bashar al-Assad, tyrant and murderer though he is, and seek to establish an organized force to combat Daesh on the ground. Daesh presents the immediate threat – they must be the priority. Air strikes can only go so far. Next, state leaders should put their weight behind the creation of safe havens in the areas of Syria free from Daesh, secured with an international UN peacekeeping force.
France should not, and will not, bow down to terrorism. The international community has commendably and wholeheartedly emphasized their support in this ongoing struggle, but pledges of solidarity cannot last forever. This fight requires genuine commitment, pragmatic diplomacy and real results.
Photograph: United States Library of Congress (Paris 16 via Wikimedia Commons)
