Pachelbel’s Canon: D-mystifying the literary tradition

By Thomas Barber

When English Literature freshers received their reading lists over the summer vacation, they were confronted by a selection of texts quite unlike any that has been taught by Durham’s English Department before. Whilst Shakespeare’s Hamlet and Marlowe’s Dr Faustus were quite uncontroversial additions to the department’s new-look ‘Introduction to Drama’ module, and Jane Austen’s Emma marched into its place in ‘Introduction to the Novel’ with all the calm self-assurance that one would expect from its protagonist, the Department of English Studies also decided that it was time to depart, in places, from such recognisably canonical texts. John Gay’s satiric musical play The Beggar’s Opera is now to be lectured on alongside Shakespeare and Shelley, whilst Alan Moore and David Lloyd’s graphic novel V for Vendetta concludes the lecture series on novels. So, what do these subtle but no doubt revolutionary syllabus changes mean for the canon, and canonicity, as a concept? The answer can, at least in part, be found in an almost entirely unrelated canon: Johann Pachelbel’s Canon in D, or more popularly, Pachelbel’s Canon. Looking to the performance history of this now instantly recognisable piece can tell us a great deal about how we could, and perhaps should, approach the canonicity of works like V for Vendetta.

We might firstly glean from Canon in D, as Ann Radcliffe sagaciously informs us in The Mysteries of Udolpho, that ‘there is no accounting for tastes’. Pachelbel’s piece initially wallowed in relative obscurity, until being propelled into the red-coated ranks of public opinion by Jean-François Paillaird’s 1968 arrangement, where it evidently found its mark. The new, slower form of Canon in D, originally scored for three violins and basso continuo, and paired with a gigue, was an instant success. Such a remarkable revival serves as a definitive example of the straightforward but easily overlooked notion that tastes change. Literature, as with the arts as a whole, and indeed life, is anything but static, and there is no reason whatsoever for the literary canon to be exempt from this. The belated canonisation of Canon in D is a well-aimed riposte to the specious assertion that a static and unassailable canon of works, however well-fortified it may be, can ever form the entire embodiment of value in a field of the arts. By departing in places from the core of texts that make up the literary canon, Durham’s English Department is acknowledging the irresistible forward march of taste.

Secondly, and perhaps more importantly, Canon in D muddies the battle lines between tastes, genres and cultures. Its prominent chord progression, that for decades invaded weddings and public ceremonies, was the same chord progression that, throughout the 1970s and 1980s, battered down the barricades between ‘high culture’ and ‘low culture’, forming the backbone of much modern pop music. From Kylie’s I Should Be So Lucky and The Farm’s All Together Now, to Monty Python’s Decomposing Composers, Canon in D has undoubtedly been one of the most significant 17th century influences in modern pop music. Indeed, it would not be at all an exaggeration to place Pachelbel alongside Verdi and Wagner when we say that the pianos they played are still working, but they’re both six feet underground. This necessarily raises the question: why should the same material – issues of originality aside – be inherently more valuable in one form than another? The same question can and should be asked of literature and the literary canon. Just as the difference between Canon in D and I Should Be So Lucky, the difference between the anti-heroic protagonist of V for Vendetta and the Byronic hero so favoured by the canon, is at most one of a differing formal representation of the same chords. The reason, therefore, why one should be inherently more valuable than the other is an issue of subjective and unstable judgements of taste – the same judgements of taste that both snubbed and lauded Canon in D.

It seems then, that Durham’s Department of English Studies, in continuing to modernise and revolutionise their syllabus, is recognising that there is simply no accounting for tastes, and that tastes might not in fact be as different from one another as they first appear. So, when we think of the literary canon, we should perhaps follow this example, and think, at least in spirit, of Pachelbel’s Canon also.

Photograph: Jeremy Carbaugh via Flickr