Poetry is dead: A reply
By Thomas Barber
In her recent article, Sarah Fletcher convincingly argues against the claim that ‘poetry is dead’. It is difficult to find fault with her demonstration of the manner in which poetry, chameleon-like, constantly stumbles upon new guises with which to rejuvenate itself. Nor can one ignore her plea that we abandon a specious yet persistent comparison between poetry and prose. However, underpinning her article is the assumption that when we claim that ‘poetry is dead’ what we really mean is that ‘poetry is extinct’. This being the case, I need not be forgiven a rhetorical indulgence for brief metaphorical recourse into the animal kingdom. Extinction is variously defined, but we can generally accept that when a species becomes extinct it has no living representative: its death rate has exceeded its birth rate usque ad finem. Whist it may be tempting to compare poetry to the Malagasy Turtle Dove or the Western Black Rhinoceros (a temptation we have all no doubt succumbed to at one time or another), contemporary poetry is, if the metaphor must persist, a donkey: a species sharing enough genetic material with the Hyracotherium so as to render its fortunate genetic ancestor only pseudoextinct. Leaving aside the matter of whether poetry is a dove or an ass, it is certainly not extinct. Poetry is read, poetry is written, poetry is, as Sarah Fletcher rightly points out, ‘becoming newer and more varied everyday’.
Yet the mourning for poetry is so unceasing that one begins to wonder if there is not some truth in the claim that ‘poetry is dead’. We can hardly begin to dissect such a claim without first considering what it means to be dead and what happens when we die. Let us imagine that we are in fact dead. What would happen to us? Most of us, if we are lucky enough, will be remembered; we will likely be given a death certificate, an obituary, a headstone, a grave. We are in all of these cases monumentalised by those around us. It is no surprise, then, that Sartre sees death as a supreme act of generosity, in which we are given over entirely to the Other. By this he means that we are unable to give expression to our own understanding of ourselves: the privilege of giving a faithful interpretation of our lives is given exclusively to others. Is this not how poetry exists? Is the creation of a poem not an act of supreme generosity? The idea that the reader is solely responsible for the creation of poetic meaning is no doubt a cliché, but poetry has nonetheless necessarily divested itself of any obligation to give a coherent understanding of its own meaning. It has by its very nature given itself over entirely to the other, to us, the reader. Thus poetry is not merely dead: it has never been alive.
Not only is poetry dead in the very loosely Sartrean sense given above, but it must be dead to be poetry and could not be poetry otherwise. To illustrate this we might turn once again to Sarah Fletcher’s recent examination of the issue, and in particular her fascinating thoughts on Noel Fielding’s stand-up comedy. She identifies his remarks on ageing as possessing a poetic quality, as being ‘sad and reflective rather than funny’. Why is it that her reading is so convincing? It is certainly not the melancholic tone of the would-be poem; the recent headline ‘South Africa level series despite Root ton’ is melancholic, but it certainly isn’t poetry, no matter how it is arranged on the page. What makes poetry out of Noel Fielding’s stand-up comedy, then, is the fact that it is also comedy. It can be both melancholic and not melancholic depending on what we choose to do with it. It is poetry because it is so completely given over to the interpretation of the other, because it is so completely open and ambiguous in how it allows us to read it, because it is so dead.
It seems, therefore, that to protest that poetry is not dead is to bring about the extinction of poetry. So next time someone tells us that ‘poetry is dead’, mournfully or otherwise, we should sit smugly in the knowledge that, by virtue of that fact, poetry is very much alive and well.
Photograph: Antti T Nissinen via Flickr
