Labour Whip Resignations: Disunity and Disaffection
By James Lindsay

Lord Grabiner became the second peer in five days to resign from the position as Labour whip in the House of Lords. Citing Mr Corbyn’s “terribly damaging” proposals and “disarray” in the party, Lord Grabiner said that he could not “square [staying] with my conscience”. He follows Lord Warner in relinquishing the position; however, both members have maintained they will not defect to another party. Lord Grabiner is to assume a role as crossbencher.
Following a dramatic rise to prominence, and a stunning election victory in September, Jeremy Corbyn must have felt like a man under pressure. There was huge anticipation as to how he would cope with the responsibilities of being leader of the opposition, his career having never progressed further than the backbenches, and people, some nervously, some gleefully, wondered whether he would be able to unite his party. A lot of people wished he would fail. Yet after a polished, if dull, first speech at the party conference and an original, if rather ineffective way, of conducting Prime Minister’s Questions, it was generally accepted that for the time being Mr Corbyn had steadied the ship.
Mr Corbyn does, after all, have a huge mandate to lead the party. His appointment would have been viewed as a real shock in the wake of Labour’s dismal performance at the 2015 General Election, but, as the leadership contest advanced, his success almost took on a kind of inevitable air. Either way, any talk of a coup must surely be premature and it seemed as if Labour MPs were resigned in accepting the result.
Criticism however has become more vocal recently with the emergence and development of the new set of Labour policies. Mr Corbyn admitted himself that being leader of a party involves a fair amount of compromise, but along with his determined supporters was at pains to emphasise the role of open debate and a climate where everyone can civilly agree to disagree. Certainly, Mr Corbyn would have known that his stance on Trident would polarize, given that the party committed to renewing the deterrent under Ed Miliband and the previous Labour government. But he seemed happy enough to accept this. And we probably should not be too harsh on a man who is simply sticking to his principles. For all the criticism he has received, going back on a position he has held since joining the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (CND) as a teenager would have appeared highly hypocritical; a betrayal to himself and his followers.
In this era of a ‘new kind of politics’, so cherished and championed by Labour activists, and more specifically the Corbynistas – whereby debate is conducted in a civilised manner; where each MP is entitled to his or her own opinions; where traditional politicians’ vague, evasive rhetoric is rejected – perhaps Mr Corbyn welcomes honest displays of dissent and disapproval, but how about resignations?
The recent resignations are not going to bring down Mr Corbyn’s government. Neither are they, in themselves, especially worrying for Labour. Lord Grabiner and Lord Warner are both in their seventies and are perhaps approaching their best-before date anyway. Moreover, it was surely to be expected that some party members would resign as a result of Labour’s new direction. However, the muted response from the party speaks volumes. With the fear of further alienating MPs, despite the strong criticism directed at the administration, a Labour spokesperson welcomed “Tony [Grabiner]’s continued membership and support of the party”. Yet ‘support’ seems far from the truth when ‘Tony’ has called the party’s new proposals “terribly damaging”.
The worry for Labour and Mr Corbyn is a developing uneasiness in the party; an insidious growth of dissatisfaction that might become more and more vocal, displaying a disunity, which has negative impacts on two levels. The first is fundamental to the functioning of an effective democracy. No matter how formidable and able a governing party, it must be kept in check with a competent opposition. A party struggling with internal battles cannot do this.
The second involves the very future of the Labour party. It is universally known that Labour MPs did not, in their majority, support Mr Corbyn in the leadership contest. Scraping onto the ballot paper with the minimum 35 MP nominations required, it was generally accepted that Mr Corbyn would represent the far left of the party. His defeat would then silence that faction once and for all, Mr Miliband having towed a similar far-left line in the general election. After Mr Corbyn’s victory and now with Lord Warner and Lord Grabiner’s recent resignations, amidst vocal criticism from Lord Mandelson, a former cabinet minister, there is a risk of an inoperable split emerging.
Labour MPs, and indeed much of the nation, were shocked at the success of a man to whom much of Mr Miliband’s failings can be attributed. Mr Miliband was dismissed as un-priministerial, too left wing; some MPs may begin to feel the same about Corbyn. Lord Warner went as far as to say Labour did not have a “hope in hell” of winning the next election. If the policies continue to disaffect and resignations continue, maybe the Labour party as we know it will not even exist by the time those elections come around.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are not representative of Palatinate, and are those of the author only. If you disagree with the opinions expressed, or would like to write for Palatinate in response, please contact the Politics section at politics@palatinate.org.uk.
Image: DonkeyHotey via Flickr
