Points of view from the Durham #BlackLivesMatter protest

By Charles Bland

Everyone at Saturday’s #BlackLivesMatter protest knew that they had a reason to be there. Everyone had individual motivations, passions and hopes which urged them to attend the demonstration. Everyone, furthermore, was taking a risk – risking the transmission of coronavirus, risking an encounter with counter-protesters, even risking a breach of what remains of the lockdown rules, which forbid gatherings of more than six people. Yet none of these hazards deterred the hundreds who covered Palace Green in a remarkable display of reflective solidarity and horrified anger at the events in the US. I interviewed some of those who showed up to the protest – as well as a few who came out in opposition – to uncover the thoughts and emotions behind the demonstration.

It is not surprising that many protesters cited the events which have unfolded in the US over the past two weeks as an inspiration for Durham’s protest. Greg Venyo, one of the organisers and a speaker at the event, said that he wanted the demonstration to be part of a “ripple effect”, which would carry the message about George Floyd’s death from the US around the world. Floyd, whose death at the hands of Minneapolis police last week sparked demonstrations worldwide, was remembered by the crowd, who kneeled silently for eight minutes and 46 seconds, the amount of time a policeman kept his knee on Floyd’s neck to restrain him. His name was also chanted. For Shelby, an American postgraduate in the Archaeology department at Durham, it was a chance to overcome her distance from the ongoing turmoil in her home country. “It hurts my heart,” she said of the events in the US. She is unable to join her friends and family who live there, and she also knows people for whom the emotional toll of the events prevents attendance at a protest. “I’m standing up for them.”

none of these hazards deterred the hundreds who covered Palace Green in a remarkable display of reflective solidarity and horrified anger at the events in the US.

However, the sights of the organisers and attendees were not just focused on the racism and police brutality across the Atlantic. Greg also stated his aim to “question unconscious bias” and “make people aware of racism in the UK.” Speakers repeatedly pointed out the UK’s complicity in racism, raising the case of Belly Mujinga, a black railway worker, who was spat at by a man claiming to have coronavirus in April, and who later died. Some attendees, many of whom study at Durham, also aired concerns which were closer to their own lives as university students. One placard in the crowd read ‘De-colonise Durham Uni’. I also spoke to a member of St Aidan’s College, Irenitumi, who said that, as a black man, he has had “an interesting time” at Durham. “The culture is different,” he elaborated. However, he was heartened by the strong presence of Durham students at the protest, observing that it was good to see so many supporting the #BlackLivesMatter movement.

The real-life display of support for the movement, both on Palace Green and in other cities in the UK, was not a given. On the contrary, several figures from the government and police have urged people not to vent their frustrations en masse in the streets, due to the possibility of spreading coronavirus, and the certainty of exceeding the limit of six people allowed at a single gathering. Dame Cressida Dick of the Metropolitan Police explicitly warned that the protests were “unlawful”. How did protesters in Durham feel about the risks?

Greg, one of the organisers, said it was a tough decision to go ahead with a physical protest, as opposed to an online event. He admits that social distancing at the event “hasn’t been ideal” due to the numbers in attendance. However, the organisers spoke to the police and received approval of their plans, allowing them to go ahead. A mass demonstration “sends a bigger message”, supporting a more vociferous expression of people’s opinions. Maisie, a protester, agreed that the issue of racism should not be pushed back by coronavirus. “It has to happen now,” she declared. Irenitumi pointed out that the size of the crowd demonstrated the urgency of the issue of police brutality: “Everyone knew the risks and decided to come. It speaks to the issues being more important.”

the issue of racism should not be pushed back by coronavirus.

Not everyone on Palace Green was enthusiastic about Saturday’s events. I spoke to a group of men who surrounded the monument to the Durham Light Infantry’s Victoria Cross recipients, located just beside the steps down to Bailey Court on Palace Green. None of them would give their names. They were not counter-protesters, they claimed, but were only “protecting our city” against rumoured plans to deface various memorials in the city centre. However, asking them about #BlackLivesMatter dispelled any illusion of neutrality. “It’s propaganda,” said one, summing up the general scepticism of the party. “Everyone’s a puppet, I can see the strings,” said another, referring to the protesters. An older man, dressed in a suit with the regimental colours of the DLI, and wearing its cap badge, went further, claiming that the “media, police and justice system are against the white man.” When asked about the case of George Floyd in particular, he responded by denying that Floyd was the victim of police brutality in the first place. “He died of a heart attack!” And if Floyd had been a soldier, would that have changed his opinion? “He wouldn’t have died, then.”

Nevertheless, it is abundantly clear, from the relative sizes of the original protest and the crew of self-appointed monument conservationists, which voice echoes louder in Durham. The final word goes to Shelby. “I hope this is a time for non-black people to swallow their pride, swallow their ego, to listen, to learn, and to be brave. Like black people have to be.”

Images: Sunita Ramani