Can we still have children in the climate crisis?
By Charles Bland
It is at once beautiful and horrifying that we have the ability to procreate. Through an act evolved to be as swift and automatic as possible, nearly all of us can start the process which leads to new life. Thereafter, we will dedicate our lives to ensuring that our child is comfortable, happy, and that it will outlive us. Probably, we pray that our child will come to make the same kind of decision which led to its own existence, and that, swarmed by grandchildren in the twilight of our lives, we can rest proud and glad of having done our genetic duty. But perhaps this is all wrong – perhaps this most natural and unquestioned desire to reproduce is one we should resist.
What is wrong with having children, then? Quite simply, it is that by having children one brings more consumers – of power, of manufactured articles, of food – into the world. One study, by geographers Seth Wynes and Kimberly Nicholas, has estimated that an individual having one fewer child will save 58.6 tons of CO2-equivalent emissions per year, whereas avoiding air travel saves only 1.6 and eating a plant-based diet 0.8 tons per year. If these astonishing figures are taken seriously, it is abundantly clear where our real duty to reduce emissions lies.
The ideal choice is to remain childless
The study calculates the effect of having one fewer child by holding an individual responsible for half of his children’s emissions, a quarter of each grandchild’s emissions, and so on. Admittedly, this has been criticised for ‘double-counting’ the emissions of each child, since it imputes responsibility for the emissions both wholly to the child and also partly to each parent. Regardless, the point of the study is clear enough: reducing air travel, say, cuts down on one’s own emissions, but having one fewer child relieves the planet of an entire lifetime of greenhouse gas output.
Therefore, the environmental imperative for humans to be less fruitful is clear. Once one has seen it, it becomes the elephant in the room accompanying every discussion about climate change. Of course, questions and objections remain. How far must we go in limiting the size of our families? Is it enough to imitate the Duke and Duchess of Sussex, who have vowed to have a maximum of two children (or, as the Sun headline put it, ‘Not one sprog more at Frogmore’)?
Having children brings more consumers into the world
The answer to this must be that, the fewer children one has, the better. It is akin to the situation with meat-eating: being a carnivore only one day a week is better than being one full-time, but it is, so we are told, even better to give meat the chop altogether. Thus, the ideal choice is to remain childless.
It is no good objecting that our children will live more sustainably in the future, as technology improves, and thus that their impact on the environment will be negligible. You, the average reader, might start having children in ten years’ time, and probably no more than twenty years from now. It is far from certain that the lifestyle you will pass down to your children will be a carbon-neutral one.
Perhaps this most natural and unquestioned desire to reproduce is one we should resist
Should we be obliged to think so coldly and abstractly about one of the most personal and emotional decisions we will ever make? Should one give up a deep desire to have children for the sake of something as nebulous and remote as ‘the future of the planet’? The rational answer seems to be yes. Whether this is too tough to swallow is up to the individual. But, whatever you decide to do, I implore you to think about it first.
Photograph by John Englart via flickr
