Peter Capaldi: the Doctor is in
By Kieran Moriarty

As the 50th Anniversary episode of Doctor Who reached its spectacular finale, viewers were presented with a heroscopia of the previous Doctors, all gathering to save Galifrey. The older regenerations portrayed from archive footage (and Eccleston of course), along with the new generation trio of Hurt, Tennant and Smith were all on centre stage. At that moment, a Galifrean general exclaims in disbelief ‘all 12 Doctors!’ To which he is corrected, ‘No sir, all 13!’
Here fans received their first glimpse of the man who would become the 13th Doctor. Mad blue eyes, a furrowed brow and grey hair; introducing Peter Capaldi. In this tiny moment of this landmark episode, Capaldi became a part of the pantheon of Doctors, before his role had even begun. Doctor Who fans are renowned for being the most fanatical and loyal in the world of television. The weight of expectation when an actor takes this role is tremendous. Take a trip into the TARDIS 10 months into the future and Capaldi’s stewardship is in full swing. The question is, will Capaldi’s Doctor be remembered as fondly as those he was placed alongside in the pantheon?
In the first few episodes, the classic components of the Doctor have been on display but used intelligently, not forced into every episode. In Capaldi’s early performances, there has been the madness of the Doctor, babbling nonsense and behaving erratically, especially in the immediate aftermath of his regeneration. From his annoyance at his close friends having the audacity to tell him to go to bed when there is a dinosaur stomping around Victorian London, to fighting Robin Hood with a spoon in a swordfight, the mad eccentricity of the Doctor is pulled off with aplomb by Capaldi. This has been a fundamental characteristic of the Time Lord from the days of Tom Baker and Sylvester McCoy.
That madness blurs into general annoyance that a flawed genius should have. Capaldi’s Doctor seems annoyed with everyone and everything when people do not understand him, a fault blamed on his new Scottish persona. In this respect, Capaldi is more like Eccleston than the previous two Doctors, more sarcastic and blunt then a cheeky charmer. However that is not to say he is a grumpy old man. Capaldi has shown he can show the Doctor’s comical side, from witty one liners, brutal put downs and general silly behaviour and arguments.
Perhaps the brusqueness of the Doctor can be attributed to Capaldi’s age. At 56 years old, Capaldi is the oldest ever Doctor, a fact that resonates in regards to his appearance especially in Deep Breath. Clara cannot understand how Matt Smith has ‘regenerated’ into someone who looks significantly older. The shock of an older Doctor may be difficult to comprehend to fans of the new generation, following the poster boy for teenage girls, David Tennant, and the youngest Doctor ever, Matt Smith.
Yet this is not necessarily a bad thing. Capaldi is playing a Time Lord that is supposed to be 2,100 years old, who has fought in many battles, seen worlds burn and watched history unfold all across time and space. The grey hair and lined face seems a bit more believable than the youthful, big chinned face of Smith, in terms of the battle hardened, scarred character that the audience is supposed to believe the Doctor to be.
A final factor of an older Doctor is that it has established an important boundary immediately in regards to the relationship between the Doctor and Clara. With Tennant’s Casanova-esque incarnation and Smith’s flirtatiousness, mild sexual tension was always palpable which threatened the predictable backstory of assistant falling in love with the madman who whisks her around time and space. Much like John Hurt in the 50th Anniversary, a Doctor that is bewildered by snogging and who is oblivious to her appearance as a beautiful woman represents a refreshing departure after the last few series.
However first and foremost, the Doctor has to be a hero. No matter how perilous the situation, he always arrives on the scene, has a moment of brilliance and saves the world. Even in the first episode, when he is not even sure about what type of man he is, his natural programming ensures that he does what he has done for the last 50 years and save the day. In the climaxes of his first few episodes, Capaldi has been able to deliver those trademark grandstanding speeches in which the Doctor picks apart the best laid intentions of his enemies and then destroys them with usually, a large explosion. Even though he looks a bit more grizzled, Capaldi is still sprightly enough to do the obligatory climbing up high things, riding horses, physical fighting and running away from aliens, as the swashbuckling hero does.
Nevertheless, an important shroud of darkness still clings to the Doctor that makes him such an intriguing character. He is not an idealised hero, he is far more complex. Like Eccleston, Tennant and Smith, Capaldi has already had moments where we are forced to question this hero. This ranges from destroying hostile species with little remorse, to being cold and merciless, or as demonstrated in Into the Dalek,, seeing the anger and hatred in his soul.
So to answer the question, based on the early evidence, I believe Peter Capaldi has the makings of a brilliant Doctor. He is able to convey the characteristics that combine together to form one of the most iconic and much loved characters in television.
However Capaldi has not just recycled and tried to imitate his predecessors. Instead, he has stamped his own unique mark on the role and made it his own. If Doctor Who makes it to a 100th Year anniversary, perhaps Capaldi will be remembered as affectionately as the names of Troughton, Baker, Tennant and Smith.
