Orwell’s 1984 and Trump’s America – ‘disturbing points of comparison’?

By Tamsin Bracher

During Trump’s presidential election campaign, Matthew Norman wrote for The Independent that ‘the truth has become so devalued that what was once the gold standard of political debate is a worthless currency’. With China’s ‘Great Firewall’ continuing to censor online access, with more than 80 journalists jailed in Turkish prisons after the failed coup of July, and with ‘post-truth’ voted by Oxford Dictionaries as its international word of 2016, it is not surprising that Kellyanne Conway’s phrase ‘alternative facts’ prompted hundreds to reach again for their ragged copy of Orwell’s political dystopia. Traditional distinctions between fact and fiction have become obscured; truth has become subjective; history a literary narrative, and language, more than ever, a means of political control. ‘How,’ Matthew Norman asks, ‘did we come to [this] mass state of altered consciousness?’

Is the future as bleak as Orwell’s dystopic novel foreshadows? Is (as Noam Chomsky argues) the notion of a ‘truth seeking media […] a sham’? Has our postmodern disdain for the truth translated into a limited and limiting view of the world?

There are disturbing points of comparison between today’s society and Orwell’s fictional state of Oceania. However, Trump’s America is somewhat different.  Kellyanne Conway’s phrase ‘alternative facts’ implicitly acknowledges that the ‘alternative’ is a deviation from its ‘fact’; she admits that there is another side. What is dangerous is that Trump’s administration does not care. Josephine Livingstone (The New Republic) argues that it ‘doesn’t even try to cover up its lies. Instead, it assumes that ideological divides among the American citizenry will ensure that the lies don’t matter.’ A far cry from the totalitarianism of Orwell’s Oceania which offers lies as state sanctioned truth – ‘2+2=5’, ‘War is Peace’.

The plurality that is engendered by our ‘Global Village’ – the internet, social media, ethical relativism, ‘freedom of speech’ – is being exploited by Trump. Fragmentation is rife, certain minorities are being oppressed, and Trump offers not a ‘unified truth’ but ‘alternative’ realities. As we navigate our way through the myriad of possibilities, it is becoming increasingly impossible to know which narrative to question. Trump’s reality needs alternatives to give his version power. Blatant lies have thus become a form of political statement.

Orwell, in his proposed preface to Animal Farm, demonstrates the need to hold on to a society governed ‘By the known rules of ancient liberty.’ Let us not doubt our reason in an age of ‘fake news,’ ‘alternative facts’ and ‘truthiness’ (‘presenting something which is not true as the truth’). Counter the lies with the facts. After all – what is the alternative?

Photograph: Chris via Flickr