‘The Fall’: All Rhodes Lead to Decolonisation

By Tamsin Bracher

The Fall bills itself as ‘an insightful play about race, class, gender, sexism, colonialism and ideologies of patriarchy’. Written and performed by seven graduates from the University of Cape Town, it traces the conception and development of the student protest movements, #Rhodesmustfall and #Feesmustfall. It won two awards and several five star reviews at the Edinburgh Festival this summer and showcased at the Royal Court Theatre in London for a limited period of time.

Indigo was lucky enough to get in touch with Cast Curator, Ameera Conrad, who graduated with distinction from UCT Drama Department in 2015.

To what extent was The Fall based on the cast’s own experience?

The show began as a response to the student protests in Cape Town in 2015. Each of the cast members was in some way involved in or affected by the protests as we were all graduating students in 2015. It felt as if the story needed to be told by an authentic and sincere voice. We felt as if a lot of people were saying a lot of things about the student movements, but not a lot of people were listening to the myriad of voices within the movement. So we wanted to represent not only our own experiences, but also the experiences of our friends and comrades who were occupying and marching alongside us. We consider the play to be 60% our own stories and experiences and 40% the stories and experiences of the people around us. The central theme is decolonisation; from that we explore issues of institutional racism, microaggressions, patriarchy, gender, colourism, classism – all of the issues which fall under the umbrella of decolonisation.

We felt as if a lot of people were saying a lot of things about the student movements, but not a lot of people were listening to the myriad of voices within the movement.

The response to the show’s premiere was incredible: why do you think it resonates with the audience in the way that it does?  

I think the humanness of the play and the realness of it – not necessarily that we’re such good actors that we can create a reality on stage, but that we actually lived those experiences – I think that makes the play special. I think it’s also because we don’t purport to know the answers to anything; we aim to show the audience that these characters are flawed, because we’re flawed. No one is 100% right 100% of the time, sometimes the people who you think have the same ideas and values as you can switch up when their privileges are being put under the microscope – and that’s across the race, gender, class, and ability spectrum. The show is real and raw and doesn’t attempt to be neat or wrap up politely with a bow on top – and I think people respect that, and relate to that, because life is like that.

Has it felt different performing The Fall in Edinburgh rather than Cape Town?

We changed the text a bit because we realised that we took a lot of the South African colloquialisms for granted, we wanted an international audience to understand everything that we were saying. The major difference, I think, is that there are moments in the play where black South African audiences (particularly Xhosa speaking audiences) would respond to the actors – there’s a moment especially where Sihle Mnqwazana’s character Zukile-Libalele is doing a praise poem calling on his ancestors, and at home we’d have audiences ululating, clapping, calling the names with him, things like that. Cultural things that are specific to -of colour South African audiences were different, but there was still an incredible response to the show from our international audience.

No one is 100% right 100% of the time, sometimes the people who you think have the same ideas and values as you can switch up when their privileges are being put under the microscope – and that’s across the race, gender, class, and ability spectrum.

Since the play was first performed, do you feel there has been important progress towards decolonisation (what exactly do you mean by ‘decolonisation’)?

When we say decolonisation, we’re referring to the dismantling of systems which exclude people of colour, we’re talking about a deeper look at the canon of work which is studied at university and school levels, and including the achievements of people of colour, we’re talking about giving people of colour the respect that they deserve, we’re talking about removing the symbols of colonialism, we’re talking about admitting to the fact that not everything that is related to modernity comes from the West. I think there’s definitely been an international conversation which has opened up since 2015 – I’m not sure if it’s just that people now have more access to the international conversations through social media, but it feels like with #RhodesMustFall and Black Lives Matter and all of the other black consciousness movements happening around the world that at the very least people are demanding that the issues be addressed. I think the clear step is the removal of all statues and symbols which glorify oppressors – statues of Rhodes, Columbus, Livingstone, all of these conquerors, can’t exist in 2017 in positions of adoration. If they belong anywhere, they belong in a museum.

Abel Bede recently argued in Palatinate that statues of people such as Robert Lee and Cecil Rhodes should remain standing in Britain else ‘we are only slowly confirming a narrative that our nation always stood on the right side of history without a question’. How would you respond to this?

History is a funny thing – I think we all can and should accept that writing history is not this neutral and unbiased thing that we should respect unequivocally. History is written by the victors, by the powerful, by the rich. There are some history textbooks in South Africa which claim that Cecil John Rhodes was a man ahead of his time who gave opportunities to Africans in a time when his peers were not doing the same. But that’s just not true. I think if people argue for history then those statues should be put in museums where we can debate who is right and who is wrong, where we can read long descriptions of who these men were and what they did, not in the middle of streets and gardens where we basically deify and idolise them. I’m a believer that if the history that is currently written is excluding a particular narrative (as most of it does) then we should be re-writing it to include those narratives, or at the very least we should be creating a new canon of history to include the voices of the marginalised. Where’s the statue of Harriet Tubman in the United States? Where are our statues of Saartjie Bartman in South Africa?

Statues of Rhodes, Columbus, Livingstone, all of these conquerors, can’t exist in 2017 in positions of adoration. If they belong anywhere, they belong in a museum.

What do you hope to achieve by dedicating your Fringe prizes to ‘all activists and movements working towards the dismantling of systems, structures and symbols of oppression’?

We recognise the work that activists are doing around the world towards the dismantling of oppressive structures and symbols, and we wanted to show that we stand in solidarity with them. This is a fight that we have fought and are continuing to fight in our own country. The most amazing thing to us was to have people of colour from all over the world telling us that they are dealing with the same issues as we are in South Africa – artists from California, Australia, London, all related to the show on a very real level, and knowing that you’re not alone in your fight is an incredible thing. We wanted to show ourselves as part of a global community of artist-activists.

How have you tried to convey in The Fall the movement’s ambitions go far beyond visual representations (for example, statues) of colonialism?

There’s a large debate in the first 20 minutes of The Fall where we make clear that the issues go far deeper than the signs and symbols of colonialism and oppression – because colonialism is also not the beginning and end of oppression around the world. It’s easy to say that we should just remove things and everything will be alright, but we need to address these issues at their roots. We can’t just chop the top of the weeds off, we need to pull them out entirely and sow new seeds.

Photograph: Oscar O’ryan, of cast members Zandlie Madliwa and Cleo Raatus