Love film; hate Oscar-bait

By Daniel Gibson

The Oscars are a strange beast. Somehow, their position astride the tail-end of February consistently casts a golden shroud over the films submitted every year in the three months prior; as though the Academy members have the collective memory span of a small child.

For the casual moviegoer, the slew of biographical dramas and theatre adaptations released each winter in the run-up to award season is a constant source of amusement. Or perhaps I’m just being cynical and Martin Scorsese really does have a yearly film-making Gantt chart that happens to end the week before Christmas Day.

In any event, the clear preference of the Academy for certain genres of film has led to a distinct “Oscar-baiting” trend which now almost parodies itself. The formula is clear to see: the Academy voters have a penchant for biopics, triumphs against adversity and anything that stars Meryl Streep.

Big sweeping themes on race, sexuality or terminal illness are also major plus points for any wannabe Oscar nominee. The upshot of this is that we end up with three months of the year where it’s impossible to move for all the untold heroes whose stories are now making the silver screen replete with a soundtrack by Alexandre Desplat.

Over the past decades, this template has been rewarded time and again by the Academy. And somehow, these films ring hollow as a result – sure, you’ll initially leave the cinema deep in thought about what you’ve just seen, but the sense of audience manipulation is palpable, and the film doesn’t linger with you for more than a day or so.

Spotlight, Birdman, 12 Years a Slave and Argo have all won Best Picture in recent years, and are all good films – but have I felt compelled to re-watch any of them? Not one. The art of producing a film that you’ll appreciate but never want to view again is something the awards season appears to have honed to a T.

When I sit down to watch any Oscar-nominated film in recent times, I’m not filled with excitement, but rather with trepidation. I know what’s coming. We all know what’s coming.

The reasoning for this seems to be that the template for “this is how an award-winning movie should look” has typically come at the expense of entertainment. When I sit down to watch any Oscar-nominated film in recent times, I’m not filled with excitement, but rather with trepidation. I know what’s coming. We all know what’s coming.

Some take the hard-viewing route, trying to leave us with a sour visceral taste and a horror at the depths mankind can reach. Others go for the feel-good, triumph of perseverance route; giving us a brief moment of cheer that’s cheapened by the knowledge that nothing is ever quite as black and white as the film shows. For whatever reason, the weight of a movie’s themes has become considered synonymous with its quality, and lighter yet more entertaining material is overlooked.

But this year has shaped up rather differently to its predecessors. At the forefront of course is La La Land, one of only two musicals (alongside Les Miserables) to be nominated for Best Picture – and a small shelf’s worth of other awards – since Chicago in 2002.

Whether this is due largely to the film’s Hollywood setting is a matter for debate, but the manner in which both it and the theatre production Hamilton have already captured the public imagination over the past year means that musicals are very much back in the mainstream.

You could also be forgiven for doing a double-take, but the film with the second-most nominations is (gasp) a sci-fi: Arrival. Whilst science-fiction films do make the list on occasions, they are typically palmed off with the Best Sound Editing or Best Production Design awards. Not so this time; Arrival is also nominated for Best Director and Best Adapted Screenplay too.

That’s not to say that the standard biographical fare isn’t still present. Hidden Figures, ‘the untold true story of African-American female mathematicians behind NASA’s 1960’s space programme’ and Hacksaw Ridge, ‘the untold true story of an American pacifist combat medic who refused to carry a firearm to Okinawa’ both have nine nominations between them.

What’s perhaps more telling is how many other films cut from a similar cloth have barely registered on the Academy’s radar. Gold, Bleed for This, and The Founder have all been met with a collective shrug from the critics. Collateral Beauty and Billy Lynn’s Long Half-Time Walk were actively panned. Even Scorsese’s passion project, Silence, has been released to just that from the Academy, with only a solitary nomination for ‘Best Cinematography’.

It’s entirely possible that the natural order of Oscar nominations will right itself next year as we are doubtlessly inundated by a fresh wave of biopics. But alternatively, we may very well be witnessing a shift at the Oscars away from the standard cookie-cutter ‘drama with a universal theme’ towards the inclusion of other genres. Who knows, one day an animated picture may be given serious consideration (I kid, that will never happen). Like the cast of La La Land, we can only dream.

Photograph: Lionsgate