Open, Heaven by Seán Hewitt: Dylan Thomas Prize Shortlist review
By Alexandra Bance
An intimate, visceral read, Open, Heaven by Seán Hewitt captures the essence of what it means to be young and in love, with all the uncertainty that comes with it. As a novelistic debut, Hewitt eloquently crafts a heart-touching tale and leaves the reader wanting more… for better or for worse.
James — an anxious, empathetic teenager coming to terms with being outed and the struggles of caring for his younger brother, Eddie — finds himself an outcast amongst his family and the village. His days are filled with the mundanity of small-town life and a lonely existence among his peers when the enigmatic Luke arrives and James finds himself helplessly drawn to his unruly charm. Trying to balance his responsibilities as a brother, a friend, and maybe a lover, James must confront the uncertainty head on and discover what it means to be true to himself when everyone around him expects differently.
This book perfectly portrays first love: the exhilaration of falling for someone, the hope they’ll fall for you, and the almost unhealthy obsession that comes with it
This book perfectly portrays first love: the exhilaration of falling for someone, the hope they’ll fall for you, and the almost unhealthy obsession that comes with it. James’ temperament was youthful, naive, and wholly relatable. James’ mood changed whenever their relationship shifted and as a reader, you couldn’t help but be pulled along with him for the journey. His hope for something more tugged on the heartstrings whenever Luke gave him the slightest bit of attention and you could feel his heart shatter alongside yours when he dismissed him. Luke’s inconsistency was frustrating and made James that much more human — trying to hold onto someone who didn’t appreciate him in the same way. As a reader, it was confusing as to what James saw in him, lacking the impact of what could’ve been such a strong relationship. However, this irrationality depicts love at its very core — its irrationality which doesn’t need to make sense to be powerful.
Unfortunately, Luke seemed to be James’ personality more than anything, and though this showed the depth of his attachment, it prevented his character from developing to the extent it could’ve; it would have been nice to see his life outside of someone else. He was not alone in this lack of development either. Arguably the most memorable character, Eddie, had a plot line that was never resolved and Mia embodied an almost throwaway tangent. As side characters, naturally, their function is to support the protagonist’s story, but their presence arguably took away from the main focus in an unsatisfying way. Present-day James also seemed like an unnecessary addition to the story considering his brief and unenlightening appearances. He showed the doomed love story of James’ past from the beginning and added nothing of value except a sense of tragedy and frustration. These intrusions acted almost as a spoiler, rather than a worthwhile proleptic device. Luke himself also didn’t appear to have a very developed character with his personality resting on being the rebellious boy-next-door rather than a fully-fleshed, genuine teenager, let alone a love interest. His omnipresence through James’ longing grew old when his actual character didn’t add much in ‘reality’.
Luke’s inconsistency was frustrating and made James that much more human — trying to hold onto someone who didn’t appreciate him in the same way
However, the plot itself was fast-paced and engaging; the prose was beautiful in its depictions of the emotional and natural realities of James’ life. Emotive and atmospheric, the writing elegantly portrayed the tranquillity of English countryside amid the turbulence of love. It was an easy read to get attached to, and left you wanting more.
Overall, a quick, beautiful read full of longing and young love. As a debut novel, Hewitt definitely set a high bar and I’m excited to see what he brings to the table next.
Image: Vintage via Amazon.

