To Rest Our Minds and Bodies by Harriet Armstrong: Dylan Thomas Prize Shortlist review
By Jemima Anson
Content warning: brief mention of suicide.
Harriet Armstrong’s debut novel, To Rest Our Minds and Bodies, follows an unnamed narrator’s progress through her final year at university, tracing the complex bond she develops with her neighbour Luke. Their relationship is built on tension, miscommunication and a fragile intimacy that neither character is able to confront. All of this is narrated through Armstrong’s distinctively dry, observational and witty voice that is deeply emotionally invested.
One of the novel’s most subtle, yet striking moves is its self-awareness about the literary tradition within which it is operating. The narrator insists that if she were to write a novel, it would be “trapped inside the mind of some girl” who might “think about motion and time and meaning but it would never extend beyond that”. Yet Armstrong’s novel insists that the two categories are not mutually exclusive: the first-person narration does not negate a universally engaging, conceptual exploration of love, intimacy, and self-identity. The narrator shares that her favourite books are about “vaguely disembodied cerebral girls”, a stereotype that Armstrong’s protagonist both fits into and cleverly mocks. This self-referential quality gives the novel an added layer that perhaps distinguishes it from its “sad girl lit” predecessors and allows Armstrong to explore the limits and constraints of this genre whilst leading us through the demise of a destructive relationship. It seems telling that the narrator is found reading Ottessa Moshfegh’s My Year of Rest and Relaxation, an addition that speaks to the genre Armstrong is both trying to inhabit and also disrupt.
This self-referential quality gives the novel an added layer that perhaps distinguishes it from its “sad girl lit” predecessors and allows Armstrong to explore the limits and constraints of this genre whilst leading us through the demise of a destructive relationship
The novel’s form reflects many of its themes and concerns. The protagonist is concerned with the repetitive and undifferentiated nature of life, rejecting literature that divides it into distinct periods. Instead of chapters, Armstrong divides the novel into brief sections of several paragraphs, a structural choice that echoes the narrator’s own worldview; she sees her life as characterised by the “cycles of contracting and relaxing” that rule her relationship with Luke. The lack of structural division echoes the narrator’s sense that her life is a series of unending and unrelated events that seem to dissolve before they can fully materialise.
There are some shortcomings. The narrator’s friendships and relationships outside of Luke are notably fleeting and feel sidelined. Whilst the intended effect of this was no doubt to exemplify the intensity of her feelings towards Luke, and the all-consuming nature of their non-relationship, it has the effect of leaving their relationship oddly suspended. The narrator becomes frustratingly isolated from wider university and life in a way that reflects the strength and depth of her obsession with Luke. Armstrong’s perspective on university life is less concerned with ideas and politics than with the texture of daily exhaustion, the strange intimacies of shared living, and the disjointed rhythm of term time and holidays.
Although it seems evident from the beginning of the novel that Luke and the narrator will not end up together, Armstrong writes with such intensity that it is impossible not to become invested in this torturous relationship. Forged in the shadow of the “suicide beam” that runs through the ceilings of their university rooms, the narrator’s obsession with Luke documents the strange intimacy of living wall to wall with strangers in university accommodation. The novel’s title comes from Luke’s concern that if they lived together they would be unable to “rest our minds and bodies”. On one level Luke’s concerns ring true; the narrator is frequently in states of emotional turmoil caused by her obsessive relationship with him and its repercussions. She also pushes her body to its limits through uncomfortable sexual encounters with men she meets online, intense physical exercise, and freezing showers. However, this objection also sheds light on the intensity of flatmate relations; Luke and the narrator on many levels already live together, an environment that creates the unsustainable relationship of unrest that will eventually drag them apart.
Armstrong’s perspective on university life is less concerned with ideas and politics than with the texture of daily exhaustion, the strange intimacies of shared living, and the disjointed rhythm of termtime and holidays
The narrator’s self-description as “wide open and completely soft like a small trembling animal held in two hands, two hands which could crush it completely but which would not” is the kind of sentence that typifies Armstrong’s voice. Tender, precise and quietly devastating, Armstrong’s debut novel is genuinely compelling and deeply felt. Despite the bleak surface of its ending — the narrator leaving Luke’s birthday party in tears and wading into a dark lake – as she pulls herself out it left me with a subtle optimism. The ending offers no reconciliation or clarity and yet the novel closes with the sense that something has shifted. Armstrong’s novel gets under your skin by refusing to offer neat answers and trusting the reader to sit in the discomfort, marking it as a formally assured and emotionally unsparing debut.
Image: Vincent Van Gogh via Wikimedia Commons.

