Borderline Fiction by Derek Owusu: Dylan Thomas Prize Shortlist review
By Gretel Goodgame
Derek Owusu’s Borderline Fiction is not a straightforward reading experience. At times, it feels less like reading a novel and more like being trapped inside someone else’s thoughts. The novel resists a conventional narrative form; instead, it unfolds inside the head of someone who exhibits traits consistent with BPD (borderline personality disorder). It is a dense and, at times, difficult book, the difficulty of which reflects the reality of Marcus’s life, as the narrative meets him interchangeably aged 19 and 25.
The novel makes for a somewhat psychologically suffocating read, as the glimpses of relief Marcus comes close to at both stages of his life are never fully realised. In this way, Owusu subtly reminds the audience that the difficulty of the book — mental health, particularly in young Black men in the UK, is not something that can always be neatly resolved.
It is a dense and, at times, difficult book, the difficulty of which reflects the reality of Marcus’s life
In a panel discussion, Derek suggested that writers inevitably bleed into their characters, a blurring that is evident in Borderline Fiction. Disconnecting characters from reality may make for a more comfortable reading experience, but the semi-autobiographical nature of Owusu’s work creates a sobering authenticity.
The novel’s protagonist is a tricky one, but that makes him worthwhile getting to know. At nineteen, Marcus is full of a youthful hubris that is both troubling — fuelled by his turbulent upbringing and particularly complex relationship with his father — yet also strangely recognisable and nostalgic. Though his life is an intensified example, there is a sense of recognition in feeling like you have the world at your feet while still being deeply unbalanced at that age. There is a universal alignment with Marcus’s arrogance here, his surface-level belief in it, even though the fragility of his confidence is transparent to those around him, and us as readers. The frantic insecurity that underlies Marcus at nineteen becomes clear when his relationship with Adwoa collapses. He spirals, reflecting not only the breakdown of that relationship, but the realisation that “people have never really checked for me (him) like that,” and when, he really deeps it, that his “dad has actually shown him the most love out of anyone,” a gritty and isolating reflection given that his abusive and alcoholic father has been the most persistent presence in his upbringing. There is a constant pull between resentment and longing.
Though a resolution may make for easier reading, Owusu instead challenges us with something closer to reality, even at twenty-five, as the novel draws to a close
At 25, Marcus is more self-aware than at 19. He has stopped doing cocaine and has moved away from London — the anchor that chains him to his turbulent family and past. His prose becomes distinctly lyrical, marking a palpable shift from the multicultural slang of his youth. However, it becomes clear that this does not signify a linear recovery from the turmoil of 19. The shift in language raises questions about whether this change reflects genuine maturity or a pressured assimilation into what is deemed acceptable. Marcus’s challenges persist into his twenties, and despite being on what feels like the cusp of release, he remains dislocated and fraught. Owusu’s novel is owed more than a two-dimensional understanding. It’s possible to conceive the shift in tone as somewhat hollow, or, opposingly, as a sign that Marcus’s consciousness has deepened, that he has found a form of escape.
Marcus is shaped by traits associated with BPD yet never receives the vital liberation of a formal diagnosis. He knows he is “different”, but never quite reaches a point of clarity. Acknowledgement is owed to the novels ability to blend the realities of mental health, ethnic identity and masculinity into fictional literature. Though a resolution may make for easier reading, Owusu instead challenges us with something closer to reality, even at twenty-five, as the novel draws to a close. Marcus remains unable to open up, despite the presence of his cousin Stephan whose concerns appear genuine. Instead of offering the resolution we might hope for, the novel denies that satisfaction, as Marcus remains convinced that Stephan, like everyone else, does not truly care.
Owusu offers us honesty; the novel allows engagement with the reality of borderline personality disorder. Marcus’ patterns become dense and jarring, leaving the reader at a constant pull between frustration and empathy. There is a faint sense that Marcus may be able to turn away from the extreme turmoil within himself towards the collective of Pan-Africanism, introduced by San, yet recurrently, nothing seems solid. Borderline Fiction is somewhat uncharted water, and the difficulty of someone else’s mind may not appeal to every reader. Although at times uncomfortable and tricky, I would recommend the book as an expansion of consciousness, and praise Owusu’s ability in doing so for the reader.
Image: Canongate Books via Amazon.

