One in four Americans believe the Sun orbits the Earth
By Kenneth Chan
According to a 2012 study by the National Science Foundation published this year, 26 per cent of Americans think the Sun orbits the Earth. Are Americans really that blind? Well, no, not comparatively. A 2005 EU survey found 66 per cent of Europeans thought the Sun orbits the Earth. However, the more telling findings of the NSF study return to Earth, exposing Americans’ interesting perceptions of climate change and evolution.
“About 3 in 10 Americans say that ‘dealing with global warming’ should be a priority for the President and Congress…near the bottom of Americans’ list of potential priorities.” In fact, “Americans are more likely than residents of other countries to say they believe that any apparent change in temperatures is the result of natural rather than man-made causes”. We also learn, “Climate change is one topic for which substantial evidence suggests that Americans have become less concerned than in the past”.
On a side note, only 48 per cent of Americans agreed that “human beings, as we know them today, developed from earlier species of animals,” and 39 per cent agreed that “the universe began with a huge explosion”.
How can understanding of climate change actually be declining when 97.1 per cent of climate research papers between 1991 and 2011 agree that global warming is man-made and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) concluded that there is a 95 per cent chance global warming is man-made.
How can established scientific theories like Darwin’s theory of evolution and the Big Bang Theory have such a minority of support from the American people? These questions are actually easier to answer than we might expect.
For one, we can point to the continued power of Christianity in politics and the media, especially fundamentalist Christianity. Fundamentalist evangelical Christians, the intellectual descendants of the Puritans, who were forced to migrate from England to the New World in the seventeeth century, who vehemently believe in the literal words of the bible and use the bible to justify hating and inciting others to hate minority groups and denying and inciting others to deny science. Fox News talk show host Bill O’Reilly famously insisted in an interview with David Silverman, president of the American Atheists non-profit, “Tides go in, tides go out. You can’t explain that”.
Whether or not to teach creationism or evolution in science classrooms is still debated; whether or not to have mandatory prayer at schools is still debated: a ridiculous problem in the twenty first century in a country whose constitution decrees freedom of religion.
However, Christianity is losing ground in America’s public sphere. According to a 2012 Pew survey, twenty per cent of Americans now identify as unaffiliated to any religion, amounting to more than the entire Black community or the entire Hispanic community. One third of Americans under the age of 30 identify as unaffiliated.
Alongside religious extremism, there is always the power of big oil in politics. The Republican stance of climate conservatism, to protect the profits of their old friends in the oil industry, is continually evident. In the 2012 election cycle alone, oil and gas contributed over $31 million to Republican candidates, compared to less than $4.5 million to Democratic candidates. In lobbying the same year, $143.68 billion was given in what is effectively legalised bribery. This increased to $144.76 billion in 2013.
From House majority leader Rep. John Boehner and Senate minority leader Rep. Mitch McConnell to various members of congressional environment committees, climate deniers grasp at straws when they repeat Republican talking points about a lack of “consensus” among scientists, or when they point to the record-breaking storms in recent winters while ignoring the fact that global warming causes wild fluctuations in weather conditions rather than simply rising temperatures.
Mainstream media also paints the picture of an even split between those who believe in climate change and those who do not. In 2013, the Sunday talk shows on the major channels NBC, ABC, CBS and Fox dedicated just twenty seven minutes in total to the issue of climate change. Last Sunday, Bill Nye ‘The Science Guy’ debated Republican Rep. Marsha Blackburn, on MSNBC’s Meet the Press show. Bill Nye is not a climate scientist. Marsha Blackburn is a proud global warming denier whose top two donors are oil and gas, composing $38,500 in 2013-14 campaign committee contributions.
Also last Sunday, Secretary of State John Kerry rightly said, “We should not allow a tiny minority of shoddy scientists…extreme ideologues to compete with scientific fact”. It is deeply troubling when facts lose ground to myths and propaganda. It is one thing when the debate is about the possible solutions to existing problems, but when the debate is about whether the problem exists despite consensus in the scientific community it means that Americans are losing touch with reality.
Photograph: NASA Goddard Photo and Video

