We should admire those teachers willing to work for free

By Kenneth Chan

The University has been the subject of heavy criticism after the Theology and Religion department advertised for PhD students to give unpaid extracurricular seminars for undergraduate students. The University and College Union (UCU), which represents academics, said unpaid posts undermined the principles of equal pay, exploited people able to work for free and discriminated against those who could not afford to do so.

South Bailey

In a time when universities have recently come under fire earlier this year from a National Union of Students (NUS) report for underpaying and exploiting postgraduate teachers, this practice recalls the modern trend of commercialisation in institutes of higher education around the world.

In the decades since the administration of the late Margaret Thatcher, British universities have been subject to an increasing consensus among the political parties and the public that the academy should deliver its research output with a speed and efficiency parallel to that of the corporate world. We may link poor provision of teaching and the underpayment of teachers to this situation, and it is easy to blame the University for prioritizing research output over teaching undergraduates.

However, the systems of benchmarking and quality management that entered UK universities since the 1990s, which balance academics’ financial and reputative contribution to the university, have led to the bureaucratic takeover of academic research through the Higher Education Funding Council for England (HEFCE) and its ‘Research Assessment Exercise’ (RAE). This phenomenon has been criticised as replacing genuine advances in scholarship with illusory academic ‘productivity.’ The failure to realise that academic research is not an economic endeavour has resulted not only in the diminishing pay of researchers and the relegation of the scholar to the bottom of corporate hierarchy, but also erosion of the academy as the replacement of permanent contracts with fixed-term and hourly-paid workers has led to the lack of clear career pathways.

It is only in such an environment that the economic term ‘exploitation’ can have migrated into higher education. The inevitable consequence of research pressure is the sidelining of teaching, and so the insistence that all teaching work must be rewarded financially and fully becomes impossible to fulfil if teaching is to be undertaken to its proper extent. As such, although exploitation, such as it is, of postgraduate teachers is a deplorable violation of workers’ rights, the pressure should be directed at the fount of this corporate culture, the political motions.

Recently, there has been controversy surrounding students and graduates paying to work as unpaid interns. The expectations placed on graduates are so great that an increasing number are willing to not only work for free, but pay to work, in order to build an impressive-sounding CV. Although much is made of the questions of exploitation and discrimination against the less wealthy, the truth remains that internships are valuable for their practical learning and CV experience. The value gained by the intern is comparable to the value gained through formal education. Those applicants who offer more are of course more likely to be chosen; it just so happens that what is asked for and what is offered now include money.

Similarly, there are many paid postgraduate teaching positions within  the university, underpayment notwithstanding, but there will always be postgraduates who want to do more teaching for career development purposes, and who nonetheless the University are unable to hire. Is it not fair, and moreover helpful, of the University administration to provide a framework through which these postgraduates can carry out these activities?

Would you work for free? It maybe instinctive for you to reject this proposal, but that rejection is exactly what’s important: you have the choice not to do so, but the choice of those who do choose to work for free must also be safeguarded. The postgraduates designing and teaching these extracurricular seminars do so voluntarily. The seminars are not part of the department’s course structure, and may be attended by undergraduates on a voluntary basis.

Just as it is easy to paint the University in a profit-maximising light, it is no stretch of the imagination to see this seminar series as something that all participating parties benefit from. Just as in the question of unpaid internships, just because the less wealthy may be unable to afford to work for free should not preclude other aspirants who can. It certainly perpetuates inequalities, but labelling it discriminatory and exploitative is superficial.

Rather than criticising the University for not paying these volunteer teachers, we should admire the PhD students who take their own time to produce something valuable to both themselves and the undergraduates they teach.

Photograph: Cressida Peever