Gothic today
By Hatty James
One of the archetypal Gothic villains is the vampire; the monster. The atmosphere is moody, the crags are craggy and there are definitely some haunted ruins – somewhere. But where has the Gothic gone?
Today we find hundreds of books featuring monsters – vampires, ghosts, werewolves – but they are caricatures of their roots; pale imitations that are so diluted that I feel it would be offensive to imply that the sparkling vampire of Twilight has any relation to Dracula, to Frankenstein’s monster, or Gormenghast‘s entire character list.
Stoker, Shelley, Walpole and Poe; the Gothic genre is often seen as beginning in the 19th century with Frankenstein or the Modern Prometheus, but it began in the 18th century with Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto, and has a long history before Shelley’s contribution.
It is a genre that encompasses architecture and art as well as literature, and is characterised with elements of mysteries and murders, curses, hauntings, monsters (usually vampires), castles, mansions and hidden passages, fainting heroines, gloomy villains and ‘strange’ goings-on. The setting is almost a character in itself – often a castle, abbey or old building in a forbidding landscape.
It was part (pseudo)-medieval, part a reflection on European politics and the current local conditions. The Victorians embraced the Gothic with their morbid obsession with mortality. This focus on gloom and doom permeated through their literature, sparking the ‘Urban Gothic’ among other such sub-genres. The Gothic genre is huge, and not easily diluted, but this is as good as any summary on its basics.
Today, I would argue that these basic elements are more recognisable in horror fiction (think Anne Rice and Stephen King) than fantasy, teenage fantasy and what is now characterised as ‘Dark Fantasy’. But it is the monster that prevails in these other three sub-genres. The vampire is suddenly cool again. The vampire, the werewolf, the ghost and the supernatural being are now ‘in’.
These creatures have their genesis in the Gothic monster or the original mythology, but not the Gothic genre. How have these become so twisted, taken out of context and changed at will? Novels written in this genre once contained a monster, which although occasionally sympathetically portrayed (Frankenstein’s monster) was still all monster, all death and murder, and certainly not a ‘vegetarian’ cute animal, there to sleep with the pretty protagonist.
More often than not, the books I find containing vampires, especially those written by women, feature a beautiful, busty woman clad in PVA suits (think Kate Beckinsale in Underworld) with a gun and red lipstick. These women are supposed to be fearless. They are supposed to be the female alternative to the male macho protagonist. They are witches, hunters and fighters and yet, they inevitably end up sleeping with that ‘monster’ they are fighting against – because of course the monster isn’t bad. He’s just misunderstood. How did the female who started out so strong and independent become just another character in a love story? Shelley, a feminist, would be turning in her grave.
Now, before I get complaints, I am not saying that all authors who use supernatural beings in their work divert so much from the origins, neither am I suggesting that when they write they are even thinking of the Gothic genre from which they hail. But while some supernatural beings are not Gothic, a lot of them do have that historical background and most certainly the atmosphere that accompanies them into these books was created by the genre. Overwhelmingly, these stories do fit the above pattern, some more than others.
Laurell K. Hamilton’s Anita Blake Vampire Hunter series is an excellent example. The protagonist is a Marshal who kills supernatural beings. She also somehow ‘needs’ to sleep with everything that moves – and I could not be underplaying that more. I could name so many more authors and stories, mainly aimed at women and teenage girls, which follow this pattern – Rachel Caine, Patricia Briggs, Rachel Vincent and Karen Chance – for example. In some cases, I suppose, just as the male protagonist has love scenes, these too could be seen as ‘liberating’, but why are they needed? Why are they so graphic and part of the woman’s need to find her ‘true love’? Really, and more importantly – why on earth is the monster now a sex symbol? When did he, or she, become divorced from terror and mutate into a teen heart throb?
why on earth is the monster now a sex symbol?
I don’t presume to have any answers to these questions. However, I can in part understand its evolution. Even the Victorian Gothic literature was to some extent titillating, novels that woman were not allowed to read because men thought their brains would explode; so they read them anyway.
The British Gothic genre is sometimes called Gothic Romanticism and it is true that originally the Gothic did involve love stories and love. But the movement from the Gothic to a supernatural Mills & Boon is just depressing to me. These are dominated by woman authors and flourish in teenage fiction (Twilight, anyone?). The prevalence of such works means a proliferation of different ‘legends’ accompanying the monsters (different vampire ‘powers’ for example: red irises, blood that heals, hypnosis) is to be expected, and to some extent admired and encouraged, but sparkling in the sun?
That’s not mixing it up a bit, that’s looking at the glory of Dracula and the vampire’s one greatest enemy the sun and going, nah, I can rewrite hundreds of years of legend better with sparkles.
As you may have guessed, I love the supernatural and I love the Gothic. All the authors mentioned here I have read, to some degree or another, so please do not think that I am picking names at random (yes, I have read Twilight). What I want is recognition that these stories are flawed and that there should be a move back towards the Gothic before the inevitable crash of these ‘dark fantasy’ comes when the vampire is no longer selling. The Gothic is more than the monster. It is a genre and as such it should not be neglected, remembered only by the caricatures that prevail today. Bring back the Gothic and educate the new generation with real literature and real monsters, please.
Photograph: Janet via Flickr

