On the offensive

5361006615_fe52a80a17_o

By James Colville

 

Another series on the way, and already another outcry on what the “lads” from Top Gear have got up to on their latest boys own adventure. Whether we are to believe that the use of a car bearing registration H982 FKL whilst filming in Argentina was accidental or not, one thing is undeniably clear. Many people have been very deeply offended. It’s the latest incident in a long list of crimes against political correctness and sensitivity committed by the popular motoring show.

From allegations of racism, sexism and homophobia to cultural and environmental vandalism, the producers and presenters of Top Gear are no strangers to accusations of offensive behaviour. This time however, the calls to axe the show are louder than ever, and I fear the future looks bleak for Clarkson and his tribute act duo. The offence caused may have reached critical mass.

But what does it mean to be offended, and does it really matter if you are offended? Whilst many would argue that anyone has a right to be offended, others are quick to defend the right to cause offence. When someone says “I find that offensive”, what should our reaction be? Stephen Fry, never shy to express his opinion, once rather famously quipped whilst in conversation with an equally polarising Christopher Hitchens, “It’s actually no more than a whine. It has no meaning, no purpose, it has no reason to be respected.”

Being offended is not a primal emotion like fear, or a neural response like pain. It is a choice, an expression of a differing point of view. People are offended because either they have chosen to be offended, or because they are told they ought to be offended.

I am reminded of the much written about Sachsgate scandal in 2008, resulting in over 18,000 complaints being made to the BBC following a series of mildly obscene and hardly abusive voicemail messages being left for Andrew Sachs. The fact is most of the complaints were made long after the actual incident, by people who had not actually heard the original broadcast. They had been told, indirectly by the highly critical newspaper articles and news bulletins, that this was something to be offended about, and they should jolly well do something about it. I was one of the very few people who actually heard the original broadcast of the messages being recorded live on air, and I didn’t pay it much attention. It was spectacularly unfunny, extremely distasteful and made for desperately poor radio. I was unimpressed, but offended? No, and why should I be?

And so it goes for Top Gear. There will be a small number people who directly take offence at a joke aimed squarely at their expense, and they will complain. There will be a few more who don’t watch the programme but hear that something that might have upset them was said, and they will also complain. There will also be a large number of people at whom a joke is aimed at, who take it in their stride and maybe even see the funny side.

I am trained as a long distance lorry driver and I presumably ought to be offended at Clarkson’s remarks regarding the supposed link between murdering a prostitute and holding an HGV license. After all, the papers all told me I should be. Yet I’m intelligent and mature enough to understand that Clarkson doesn’t actually believe that all lorry drivers are prostitute killers. I understand that he was making a humorous observational remark basked on the fact that two very high profile serial killers, who targeted sex trade workers, were indeed lorry drivers. Hardly the pinnacle of intelligent humour I will freely admit, but I see no reason to feel personally attacked by such a cheap and ill thought out comment.

Top Gear in its current state has been on the air for twelve years now, and in that time there have been countless incidents, comments and suggestions that have provoked fury from people who, I have no doubt, have been genuinely upset by them. Those people have every right to file complaints and offer their point of view of course, but do they have the right, to take away something that is enjoyed by millions of people worldwide? I don’t think they do.

As a matter of opinion, I don’t  particularly like Top Gear and I won’t miss it when it’s gone. I also don’t like tomatoes, smart phones and Katy Perry. Tomatoes make me sick, smart phones seriously irritate me and Katy Perry, well, she also makes me sick. Only I’ve chosen not to be offended by these things; I’ve chosen to avoid them. And that’s all you need to do with Top Gear.

 

Photograph – Bob Bob