Band Aid: criticise the music not the cause
Thirty years on and whilst the lyrics have changed, the tune remains the same: patronising, misinformed, culturally insensitive and, worst of all, musically abominable. With his little black book in hand, Bob Geldof and his legion of bleeding heart superstars have rehashed the 1984 famine-focused original and produced an Ebola themed version of Do They Know It’s Christmas?
No Bob, “they” are probably are quite unaware that the festive season is fast approaching in the predominantly Muslim States of West Africa. “They” were probably similarly ignorant of the impending arrival of Yuletide in Ethiopia thirty years ago, where Christmas is celebrated on January 7th owing to the adoption of the Orthodox Calendar. The rushed and rather shoddy rewriting of the lyrics – to an already odiously condescending song – has raised much criticism in the week since its release. Google it and the first few pages of results comprise almost entirely of articles focusing on the negative reception the record has had. YouTube it and nearly all of the comments are abusively derogatory. And I think I know why.
Band Aid is a group of highly successful individuals who are mostly young and good looking. They are probably very wealthy and they are almost certainly getting more attention in the bedroom than you or I. And that is exactly what we don’t like about them. Never mind that the song itself stinks, take a look at the bunch of sanctimonious, hypocritical, egotistical and above all successful people who got together and made it happen! How dare they sing about an epidemiological crisis in West Africa, it has nothing to do with them! How dare they ask me to put my hand in my pocket to try and help the situation and how dare they force me to think about it, even for a second.
And Yet… I feel it’s symptomatic of a media generated cynicism pervasive in our society that we can no longer abide a do-gooder, much less a celebrity do-gooder. We are much less interested in the genuine benefit that the record – as crappy as it undeniably is – may have on the fight against Ebola than we are in denouncing the motives of the people that made it. But we shouldn’t be too quick to balk at the self-congratulatory tones of Bono et al lest we can remember ourselves the last time we did a genuinely selfless good deed. Personally I don’t think such a thing exists, and I see no difference in the do-gooding of Paloma Faith wailing at a microphone for half a day than I do in a Durham Student dressing up as Superman and running around the Bailey with a collecting tin.
Part of the discomfort at which I feel with regard to some of the ruder comments made against the participants of Band Aid is that they are entirely based on assumption. “Why don’t they just put their hand in their own deep pockets instead of asking me for money?” – Er, actually they do. Collectively the Band Aid members have probably donated more personal wealth than sales of the record have generated. “All the money will probably get spent on guns instead of making people better!” – No, it is probably going to go MĂ©decins Sans Frontières who I’m sure will appropriate it wisely.
I’m not defending the record, it sucks as a piece of music and the lyrics are appallingly patronising and whiff ever so faintly of white saviour superiority. I am, however, defending the intentions of those who feel they want to help in their own way. Of course it’s ego-driven, and of course it’s irritating to watch for poor, talentless and sexually frustrated nobodies like you and I, but who cares?
Lily Allen, who publically turned down an offer to guest in the recording, was right. The record is smug, and it’s probably far better to quietly and anonymously write a cheque if you want to help out financially. But Band Aid is about generating awareness too, not just of the disease but also of the social, political and economic situation in which it has so ravenously spread. In this aspect, silently writing cheques is not as effective, loathe though I am to admit it, as a collection of pocket-money popstars of whom I have either not heard of or I don’t want to hear from.
Sinaed O’Conner, who was involved, was right as well: it is smug to say that you think the record is smug. Either buy it or don’t buy it, like it or don’t like it. Feel free to criticise the philanthropies of others and question their motives but in doing so, be careful not to come across as too self-righteous yourself.
Illustration: Lucy Hogarth

