Brexit? Mind your own business
By James Colville
Being as I am, white, male and comfortable with the association between my genitals and my gender identity, I was recently surprised to find myself victim of petty minded discrimination. I believe this phenomenon already has its own “ism”. Brexitism. The incident took place a couple of weeks ago at a student orientated convention outside of Durham. After a long day of talks and workshops (which included encouraging inclusivity and diversity in student groups), I was enjoying an evening drink with some of the other speakers and attendees. Towards the evening’s end, one of the speakers approached our table and offered a lift back to the accommodation in her car. Gladly accepting we finished our drinks and began making our way out when it became apparent that the free taxi ride was on condition that you confessed your referendum vote and, I presume, that your vote was the “correct” one.
On the long walk back to my digs, through the deluge and the thunder and lightning (I may have added that detail for effect), two things in particular stood out in my mind. First, how those that consider themselves virtuous in making sure all the religious, ethnic, gender and sexuality boxes are ticked on their diversity radar screen, are often the least tolerant when it comes to intellectual diversity. And secondly, how I was proud of myself. I had stuck to my principles and kept my vote secret when it would have been so much easier to simply give the answer expected of me. So, to the person who only acts kindly to those that match their political ideology, here is a brief explanation why I choose to keep my political points of view to myself.
A comment left on Facebook by a fellow student reads something along the lines of “if you voted to leave please unfriend me now”. If I took similar action, my friend count would probably be reduced by 52%. You see, unlike a great deal of students with whom I have begrudgingly discussed the wretched Brexit debate, I don’t live in an idealist left-wing echo-chamber. Some of my friends include the grubby working classes and uneducated plebs who, I’m afraid to tell you, have a vote that counts just as much as yours and mine. Some of my friends are old folks as well; those senile selfish bigots who once upon a time we used to respect the wisdom of in our naïve youth. Some of my friends were even quite vocal in their allegiance to the Leave campaign, and on a couple of occasions, I took the precious time to listen to the reasons they had come to such an outlandish conclusion.
Far from the desperate want to keep every Muslim as far away from the White Cliffs of Dover as possible, I heard well thought out arguments for the restoration of democracy, for the accountability of elected politicians and for the opportunity to complete self-governance. I heard arguments for principle over pragmatism by educated and intelligent people who I know as a sure certainty do not possess a single atom of bigotry in their entire body. Do I agree with their arguments? Possibly not. Do I think their conclusion is justified? I guess that’s completely subjective. Does it change any part of the reason why we are friends in the first place? Not one bit. Whilst I know full well that, yes, some Leave votes probably were cast by people whose life is dominated by their intense dislike of Polish builders, I am also aware that some Remain votes were cast out of concern Britain might not be eligible to compete in Eurovision any more. In other words, stupid people vote for stupid reasons on both sides of the political fence. It doesn’t stretch my imagination too much to believe that in the same way, smart people voted for smart reasons on both sides as well.
I am a middle class anthropology student with a part time job in European travel. That may give you a clue as to where my opinions on EU membership lie. However, these are experiences that are personal to me and I understand that others who lead different lifestyles have different aspirations, face different hardships, perceive different injustices and interact in different social environments to me. If political expression is shaped largely by personal experience and not just ideology, is it a surprise that some people may think differently to me? No. In politics of this kind there is no “wrong” or “right”. There is only a majority and a minority. And you are going to have to come to terms with the fact that you and your opinion, for all your virtuous intentions, are in the minority – for all you know I am right there with you.
So I won’t tell you which way I vote because I don’t think it matters. Whether I believe in a European Union tells you about as much about my character as does my sexuality – and you wouldn’t demand I confess which way I swung in the bedroom before you gave me a lift home, now would you? I hope not. That would be homophobic.
Photograph by Jose Manuel Mota via Flickr
