Of mice and men: how useful are animals as model human systems?

By Tommy Pallett

The nematode worm, fruit fly, zebrafish, African clawed frog, chicken, and mouse. What do these animals have in common? They are the most widely studied organisms in the world. When using model organisms, the ultimate goal is to understand human biology, so why are we beating round the bush and poking at a load of other (relatively unrelated animals) to learn about ourselves?

Lab_mouse_mg_3213

The mouse of course is the most famous: the stereotypical lab animal – you have probably heard of that time a scientist grew a human ear on its back. Research groups at Durham have in fact used mice to study everything from the development of skin to how ionising radiation causes cataracts. For the latter case, Professor Roy Quinlan, from the Biophysical Sciences Institute at Durham, describes how the mouse is “an excellent animal model because of the wealth of genetic and molecular tools” available, and because “the [eye] lens is very accessible and easy to dissect.” This “accessibility” is in fact a key motivator in the use of model systems. It refers to how easy it is to study an animal without being overly invasive. In other words, can you look at an embryo at a particular stage without having to terminate its development through dissection? If the answer is yes, you’ve found yourself a pretty accessible embryo! Zebrafish are the new favourites, as their developing tissues can be imaged without dissection, enabling observation of genetic mutations and progression of disease in a living organism.

So it would seem that model organisms are the way to go – but these model animals are exactly that: models. The jump has to be made to humans, and the results obtained from a model don’t always correlate in a straightforward way. For example, Professor Quinlan notes that “zebrafish have duplicated part of their genome”, which means that in some cases where a human would have a single protein, the zebrafish might have two. Another example: mice embryos actually develop ‘inside out’ compared to human embryos – at a particular stage in development the mouse embryo flips. Surely this throws into question the applications of animal research to human biology?

Well, it does, but to dismiss them would also be a rather shallow view of the insights that model organisms provide us. Many developmental processes and strategies are universal. Take ‘segmentation’, the development of repeating body sections: many organisms use this strategy during development (for example the vertebrae in our spinal cord), and our earliest knowledge of this process was gleaned from chick embryos, which are so unlike our own. Furthermore, studies on rats have provided almost everything we know about cancer drugs; mice can be genetically engineered to serve as models for Alzheimer’s disease; and worm studies have given us everything on ageing. We can’t say the study of models has been fruitless.

In these cases we could not even consider studies with humans. Nor should we – genes are often conserved across species, so a particular gene found to cause problems in humans can be studied in a model animal that has it. It would also be rather impractical: development of a human embryo takes 9 months, a fully grown adult 18-21 years, and diseases such as Alzheimer’s up to 60 or 70 years. The fast life cycles of these models mean that the developmental process or effects of diseases can be observed with relatively little expense in both time and money.

The take away message, however, is not that models save money. Models, it turns out, are useful and, more importantly, they save human lives.

Photograph: Rama via Wikimedia Commons