NUS report finds substantial evidence of antisemitism within the institution
Content Warning: this article contains discussion of antisemitism and antisemitic language.
By Maxim Meinertzhagen
An independent investigation into alleged antisemitism within The National Union of Students (NUS) has found that the union presents a “hostile environment” for Jewish students with “numerous instances” of antisemitism resulting in Jewish students not feeling “welcome or included” throughout at least the last decade. As a result of this, the NUS has released a five-point plan designed to reduce antisemitism in the institution.
The in-depth report, led by Rebecca Tuck KC, has concluded that the current structure of NUS and its internal procedures for dealing with issues such as these, have been inadequate in combatting the presence of antisemitism in the union. In some cases, the report describes, this has led to complaints regarding the issue being ignored as they are dismissed as “groundless or bad faith allegations”.
Durham’s Student Union has responded affirming their solidarity with Jewish students saying they have a “continuous responsibility” to fight against antisemitism and that it sees this “as a first step by NUS in regaining the confidence of student’s unions, the government and – importantly – Jewish students”.
The report’s findings are based largely on individual testimonies from Jewish students with first hand experiences of antisemitism when attending NUS conferences as well as from members of the union itself and in NUS spaces in campuses. The report has been used in order to understand the nature of the antisemitic abuses they suffered as well as the union’s responses to them.
The report, described as “very damning” by president of the Union of Jewish Students, Joel Rosen, details numerous examples of Jewish students in and at NUS events being faced with prejudice and discrimination. One student who was interviewed by Ms Tuck, described their distress when another NUS member used the phrase the “final solution” in a discussion in an anti-racism committee, and was not subject to any repercussions from the NUS even after a complaint.
Others described feeling “reduced to being only “the Jew” in the room” and being “whispered about and stared at” with one explaining they felt unsafe at an NUS conference due hostile attitudes towards Israeli civilians and Zionist sympathisers.
The National Union of Students (NUS) has found that the union presents a “hostile environment” for Jewish students with “numerous instances” of antisemitism
The report identifies the large amount of attention given to issues surrounding the Israel/Palestine conflict in NUS culture, as a key cause of this antisemitism with Jewish students describing being treated as though they were “answerable for Israel”. Multiple accounts in the report even describe how these attitudes have led them to fear for their safety as one student had to be escorted by university staff at an NUS event due the crowd being “particularly hostile” towards them.
One student accused the NUS of having an “obsession” with Israel/Palestine. Many students also described being harassed with antisemitic comments in NUS spaces on campus, some describing how they had ‘swastikas’ drawn on them in freshers week, while others saw stickers and posters asserting “Hitler was right”.
Additionally, the report presents various antisemitic tweets made by individuals in and at NUS events who were not reprimanded, including one which branded Jewish people “Zionist pigs” and “scum”.
Ms. Tuck’s report advises against any sanctions on the NUS members described in the accounts given that the age of the complaints makes it unlikely that the perpetrators are still eligible members. However, the report does provide eleven recommendations involving regular antisemitism training and education for all members on antisemitism and the Israel/Palestine conflict, as well as encouraging the NUS to promote more balanced and nuanced debates on the subject.
In addition, the report suggests the creation of an advisory panel to oversee the development of these recommendations as well as a review of the complaints system to make it more effective and available to Jewish students.
Ms Tuck was commissioned to make the report by the NUS in June last year due to a series of antisemitism allegations and controversies surrounding the union such as their alleged order that Jewish students should self-segregate due to concerns over the appearance of the rapper Lowkey. As a result, the Department of Education suspended all engagement with the NUS at that time. Subsequently in November last year, the president of the NUS, Shaima Dallali, was officially dismissed over antisemitic tweets.
As part of its 5-point action plan, the NUS has said it will create an ‘advisory panel’ to scrutinise the plan which also includes measure to ensure Jewish students are permanently represented
In response to this report the NUS has released a statement on their website accepting its findings and emphasising their commitment to fighting antisemitism saying, “We are confident that the investigations have been thorough, fair, and conducted to the highest standards throughout […] there is no place for antisemitism within NUS and we are committed to ensuring that Jewish students feel safe and welcome in every corner of our movement. Antisemitism is an attack on our shared values of equality and solidarity.”
As part of its five-point action plan, the NUS has said it will create an ‘advisory panel’ to scrutinise the plan which also includes measures to ensure Jewish students are permanently represented and more extensive training for NUS members and candidates for election. The NUS also pledged to “strengthen NUS governance” in order to improve its complaints system and to ensure its events are properly regulated.
The director of NUS Kat Stark has described the report as “shocking” and that they would be implementing all of the report’s recommendations while Ms Tuck showed hope for the future of NUS saying, “I have also found the current NUS UK board to be sincere in their expressed desire to ensure their organisation is welcoming for all students, including Jewish students.”
Image: Andrew Davidson via Wikimedia Commons

