‘Minimum service levels’ – a plausible idea to combat strikes?
By Amelia Melvin
In Parliament on Tuesday 10th January, the Business Secretary, Grant Shapps, announced plans for new strike laws to ensure ‘minimum service levels’ during strike action. The proposed restrictions would impact six key public sector services including; transport, healthcare, education, fire and rescue and border security.
This came in response to reports that over a million days have been lost to strike action since June of last year – an unprecedented figure that has not been seen for over two decades. His argument adopts an ironically utilitarian approach in that in order to protect public safety and value the greater good, he must therefore limit the freedom for essential workers to strike. When Ambulance services and NHS trusts have declared critical incidents in recent weeks, and ministers have criticised the RMT rail union for ‘holding the country to ransom’, it is easy to see why the government might go to such desperate measures to appease the crisis.
Gone would be the days when strikes would significantly disrupt day-to-day life, and instil fears of not receiving adequate healthcare or education. On the surface these plans are evidently plausible. They present a quick solution to a debilitating problem. An easy-fix declaration that helps portray a party burdened by scandal and economic crisis, as seemingly in control. Unfortunately, as with any reactive legislation, the reality goes much deeper.
In announcing that the law would mean ‘millions of hard-working people across the UK will be protected from disruptive strikes’, Rishi Sunak frames the argument that the tax-payer should continue to receive what they pay for. And yet, in doing so he manages to segregate an essential part of the electorate: the trade unions and their followers. For surely if he aims to value the pockets of ‘hard-working people’ of Britain, then he must see sense in valuing the concerns of those on strike seeking adequate pay in the midst of rising inflation. So far talks with trade unions have proved unproductive, as the government remains reluctant to budge on pay packages for the current financial year.
A meeting with the Health Secretary, Steve Barclay, over pay for healthcare workers, was labelled as ‘bitterly disappointing’ and ‘an insult’ by Unite union and the Royal College of Nursing (RCN), despite Barclay moving away from a hard-line refusal over pay and proposing funding to help ease pressure. In response to discussion over the law this week, Union Leaders have threatened to hold a coordinated day of action on the 1st February that will champion the slogan ‘protect the right to strike’. It appears that compromise (an arguably more effective approach) has been forgotten in favour of order. And these plans of restrictive legislation might only add fuel to the fire.
According to Shapps the law would match legislations already present in countries such as Spain, Italy and France. This is precisely where his argument falls short. Unlike in those countries, that require minimum service levels to be agreed in advance as to organise appropriate cover and do not take any action against striking workers, Britain’s legislation proves much harsher. Once passed, the law will give employers the right to reasonably dismiss workers if they do not partake in minimum service levels whilst on strike, and Trade Unions can be held liable and sued for misconduct. The difference is that the countries which Shapps made comparisons to strictly adhere to workers’ rights as established by the United Nations in the 1966 International Covenant on Economic Social and Cultural Rights. That is to say their right to collective action without consequence is fairly protected. In the case of Britain’s proposed legislation, however, it becomes more blurred. In both limiting and penalising those on strike, Parliament risk encroaching on workers’ rights and damaging Union relationships.
Nonetheless for the NHS ‘minimum service levels’ might seem like a viable option in light of the important life-saving role they play. Section 240 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations Act of 1992 declares it an offence for industrial action to be taken if there is a possibility of endangerment to human life. Shapps’ proposals would prove beneficial in saving lives otherwise affected by the mounting waiting times the NHS face. But for public sectors like education and transport where an immediate threat to life is not apparent, a blanket legislation on the everyday worker’s right to strike seems undemocratic to say the least.
Image: Number 10 via Flickr

