The innocent on death row: how the media can play a part in saving lives
By Amelia Melvin
In 2020, three men who had been taking part in a large-scale protest in Iran, caused by unprecedented inflation of petrol prices, were arrested and sentenced to death in line with charges of inciting violence and, “sabotage” on the Islamic Republic. Amirhossein Moradi, aged 25, Mohammad Rajabi, aged 25, and Saeed Tamjidi, aged 27, were all facing execution until widespread media support managed to systematically reverse this verdict and encourage a reduction of their respective sentences to five years imprisonment. The initial court ruling garnered mass media attention, with notable figures and celebrities, including Donald Trump and former vice-president Mohammad Ali Abtahi, tweeting in support of this U-turn. The hashtag, “Don’tExecute” in Farsi, was reportedly retweeted over 4.5 million times in the space of two days, resulting in major disruption to Iranian networks. In turn, Iran’s Supreme Court ordered a retrial.
Two years later, on 1st September 2022, the Islamic Revolution Court of Urmia, located in the Iranian province of West Azerbaijan, sentenced Zahra Seddiqi Hamedani, aged 31, and Elhra Choubdar, aged 24, to death by hanging. They remain on death row in the women’s ward of the Urmia Central Prison. As reported by the human rights organisation, Hengaw, they had been found guilty of charges relating to the promotion of homosexuality, which included the, “spreading of corruption on Earth”, as well as the, “communicating” of these values on anti-Islamic Republic media, along with alleged accusations of trafficking published by a state news agency — all of which are punishable by death under Islamic law.
The United Nations has released a statement urging “Iran to repeal the death penalty”
Throughout their arrest, both Seddiqi Hamedani and Choubdar have reportedly been denied access to a fair trial with lawyers, and according to Amnesty International, have been subjected to numerous counts of physical and mental torture, including abusive threats and solitary confinement. It has been recently reported that Seddiqi Hamedani attempted suicide as a result of these abhorrent conditions. Prior to her detainment, she posted a video message to The Iranian Lesbian and Transgender Network, 6Rang, addressing the importance of her activism for the LGBTQ+ community, and urging that in case of her arrest people continue to fight for, “freedom”. This is a freedom that has been so inhumanely stripped from both her and Choubdar in the wake of their death sentences.
So far, in response to this case, the United Nations has released a statement urging, “Iran to repeal the death penalty”, for these women. And human rights organisations, including Amnesty International, Hengaw and Article19, have published articles detailing key information, with Amnesty publishing an “urgent Action” appeal letter addressed to the Iranian Embassy which activists can use. Alike to the case in 2020, there has also been widespread media publication on this ruling, and on the individuals involved, on platforms such as Twitter and TikTok. But only a few major news outlets, one of them being, The Guardian, have actually published the story. It is difficult to deny that what was achieved for Moradi, Rajabi, and Tamjidi in 2020, does not offer hope of what can be resolved for Seddiqi Hamedani and Choubdar today.Â
Elicia Le Bon, a criminal defence lawyer from the United States, recently posted a video on TikTok pleading with her viewers to follow six steps that include; reposting and engaging, tagging notable platforms, and signing a petition. Currently, it has amounted to over 266,000 likes, and over 130,000 shares. As well as referencing the aforementioned successful media outcry in 2020, Le Bon informs that, “these petitions make numbers. Numbers make news outlets interested. Those interested outlets share the stories. Those stories get the attention of International Human Rights activists. They put pressure on Iran. It works”. Let us hope Le Bon’s message rings true.
Unfortunately the circumstances of those facing the death penalty in Iran are not new
Unfortunately, the circumstances of those facing the death penalty in Iran are not new, and in what Amnesty International calls, “an execution spree”, Iran has reportedly killed over 250 people on death row between 1st January and 30th June 2022. It certainly seems hard to comprehend what, according to Diane Eltahawy, Deputy Regional Director for Amnesty International in the Middle East and North Africa, is, “the state machinery [of Iran] carrying out killings on a mass scale across the country in an abhorrent assault on the right to life”.Â
In an age where the Universal Declaration of Human Rights has become a cornerstone of modern society, the role of mass media in influencing of judiciary decisions cannot be surprising.
Image credits: Emiliano Bar via Unsplash

