‘Napoleon’ (2023): Ridley Scott’s take on France’s greatest sycophant
By Remigius Kim
“You think you’re so great because you have boats!” Joaquin Phoenix screams petulantly as Napoleon Bonaparte at the British Ambassador in Ridley Scott’s latest historical epic, Napoleon (2023).
There is no doubt that this is, simultaneously, one of the best and worst quotes in cinematic history. Unfortunately, this conflicting duality persists painfully and unwaveringly in Ridley Scott’s ambitious depiction of one of history’s most recognisable figures.
With an astounding budget of $200 million and the flashy cast of Joaquin Phoenix, Vanessa Kirby and Rupert Everett, director Ridley Scott takes on the daunting task of portraying the most revered and influential figure of French history: Napoleon Bonaparte. The film begins in Napoleon’s early life, at the Siege of Toulon, and follows the ambitious figure through major historical events such as his seizure of power, the Egyptian Campaign, Battle of Austerlitz, Invasion of Russia and his eventual downfall at Waterloo.
The problem occurs, however, when a movie has a runtime of 2 hours and 38 minutes but still somehow feels rushed and incomplete. By covering the most significant events of the Napoleonic wars, the film has the arduous mission of depicting 28 years worth of history that shaped modern France and Europe in approximately three hours. It inevitably falls short in this task, rushing through important events in an attempt to squeeze in a wide collection of Napoleon’s accomplishments, with some battles only occupying minutes and sometimes merely seconds in the film. Instead of a coherent narrative, the movie often seems to be a collection of montages with little narrative to carry them.
Due to a lack of coherence, Ridley Scott presents a compilation rather than a story
This is perhaps one of the movie’s greatest faults as despite depicting critical events in the historical figure’s life, it fails to deliver the answer to the simple question: why?
Why did Napoleon feel compelled to wage war with Austria? Why was Napoleon in Egypt? Why did Napoleon seize power as emperor when the scene prior to his grand ascension to the throne depicts his incredulity with the idea?
The film provides little to no explanation behind the drive of Napoleon’s actions. Instead, the events just seem to occur, with sometimes years between, and the audience is left on their own to speculate the reason behind Napoleon’s intent or how he got here.
The film does, however, provide a poorly developed theme as a form to address the character’s drive. The idea of destiny springs up compulsively in the narrative, oftentimes involving an enraged Joaquin Phoenix passionately declaring that his character’s greatness and conquests are promised by divine destiny. But this constant theme, despite being heavily emphasised, was an inept and deficient way to provide the character a sense of agency due to its poor execution.
Furthermore, while the movie attempts desperately to fit in as many major battles of the Napoleonic Wars as it possibly could, these depictions were plagued by short screen times and history inaccuracies. One of the film’s most gripping scenes include Napoleon firing cannons on the frozen lake at Austerlitz and drowning retreating Austrian forces. The tiny problem being… this never happened.
The scene of the Battle of Austerlitz can undoubtedly be deemed a cinematic success. The masterful cinematography, haunting soundtrack, impressive period costumes and special effects all contributed to a compelling portrayal of the brutal and horrifying majesty of Napoleon’s victory at Austerlitz. But, this isn’t enough to overcome the film’s many failings. While historical inaccuracies are unavoidable and sometimes necessary in historical fiction, the poorly structured plot of Napoleon highlights the fault of the unfaithful portrayals of history, especially when the film relies so heavily on the depiction of these events.
Ridley Scott intends on portraying events that never happened while leaving out ones that actually did
Incompleteness, in numerous factors, lies at the heart of the movie’s downfall. Instead of focusing on Napoleon’s incredible archaeological contributions to the study of Ancient Egypt, most notably his retrieval of the Rosetta Stone, the film chooses to depict Napoleon firing cannons at the pyramids which, again, never happened. By packing Napoleon’s entire Egyptian Campaign into ten minutes of screentime, the film drags out a pointless scene where Joaquin Phoenix presses his ear against an Egyptian mummy in order to emphasise the weak theme of destiny.
By attempting to fit in so many events, the film has managed to overdose on portraying all of the events while simultaneously failing to tell a story at all. The lasting impacts of the Napoleonic Code and the significant social and political change it instilled over France, Europe and indeed, the world has been completely neglected. Moreover, Napoleon’s name defining battle at Marengo was absent and most of the field marshals, who were critical to the success of the French Empire, remained unnamed in the entire duration of the film.
However, the most significant flaw of Ridley Scott’s film can be attributed to Napoleon himself. While displaying an innate capability of portraying compelling characters in Gladiator (2000) and Joker (2019), Joaquin Phoenix’s widely anticipated depiction of Napoleon is a grand and majestic disappointment. Phoenix’s portrayal of the complex historical figure was lacklustre and lifeless but the most damning downfall of Phoenix’s portrayal comes from poor characterisation, resulting in the character’s ongoing inconsistencies.
The most undermining factor of Ridley Scott’s ‘Napoleon’ is Napoleon himself
While Phoenix’s Napoleon is hauntingly imposing and fearless in scenes where he charges into battle, that same Napoleon wheezes and scampers in terror while being chased out of the national assembly by elderly, decrepit bureaucrats. In his relationship with JosĂ©phine (Vanessa Kirby), he is awkwardly sycophantic but somehow also ruthless and terrifying. At other times, Phoenix’s Napoleon is a whiny and petulant sociopath who throws childish fits that eerily resembles former US President Donald Trump’s press conferences. These shifts in character occur at random points in the narrative and often times it seems that the film just could not settle on who Napoleon is. The inconsistency fundamentally corrupts Napoleon’s development and renders his accomplishments completely accidental rather than the result of his actions.
This inconsistency is not limited to characters but is also evident in the film’s tone. The dark and grisly air of the Austerlitz scene is completely subverted by the awkward and humorous tone of other scenes involving Napoleon’s seizure of power and his relationship with his lover, JosĂ©phine. This contrast of tones results in a film resembling a dark comedy rather than the historical epic that Ridley Scott had intended.
The film also features an utterly bizarre sequence that deserves the title of the most entertaining sex scene in cinematic history. The scene in question involves Joaquin Phoenix’s Napoleon braying and trotting like a horse for the longest minute in one’s lifetime while attempting to advance onto a reluctant JosĂ©phine, who is unwilling to engage sexually because she had recently had her hair set. While thoroughly amusing, the scene has, without a doubt, undermined the consistency of the narrative’s tone.
Vanessa Kirby’s performance, contrasting Phoenix’s, was nuanced and consistent. However, this exceptional performance was again defeated by the absence of Joséphine’s agency as a character due to a lack of solid characterisation. While Kirby maintained a terrific portrayal throughout the film, the character of Joséphine unfortunately remains flat and purposeless.
Ridley Scott’s Napoleon was successful from a filmmaking point of view, featuring terrific performances from its actors, glamorous historical costumes and a compelling soundtrack by Martin Phipps. However, with little to connect these positive factors together into a coherent and riveting narrative, the film loses its control over itself as a story and inadvertently presents itself as rushed and confused telling of the life of Napoleon Bonaparte.
Images: WikiImages via Pixabay

