Measure for Measure

As one of Shakespeare’s lesser known plays Measure for Measure is not always given the credit it deserves. Though the ending is perhaps morally dubious, the play pivots between the tragic and the comic, playing on the struggle between justice and mercy in a dark and morally corrupt Vienna. The saintly Isabella is forced to choose between her chastity and the life of her brother Claudio, Lord Angelo is seduced both by power and Isabella’s purity; meanwhile the Duke makes dubious attempts to rectify it all with disguise, trickery and a few convenient marriages. The makings of a good play? Potentially.
The Hild Bede Theatre Company started well; their marketing was simple yet provocative reflecting their contemporary take on the play and I went along intrigued to see how they were going to go about it.
Music and lighting were cleverly used to infer the theme of moral corruption with the opening scene drawing the audience into a dark Vienna. A red hue infused the stage while scantily clad waitresses wandered through the audience offering their services. The use of blue light at the opening of Angelo’s scenes, cleverly indicated the icy nature of his character, subtly communicating these ideas to the audience. The set served its purpose and the use of a shadow screen was effective.
Unfortunately, marketing isn’t everything and, despite a good start, Measure for Measure failed to be consistent throughout. Tom Bowden’s performance of the Duke at times lacked fluidity and therefore compromised the credibility of his character. This is not necessarily Bowden’s fault as he could have been aided by better direction had a clear decision been made about the true nature of the Duke and his intents. The role of Escalus as mediator was recognised and Aveneesh Sharma played the role well. Owen Shipman provided us with an Angelo whose vivid battle between morality and lust was compelling and was one of the stronger actors in the show.
Kla Shipton’s performance as Isabella had moments of brilliance where her anguish was clearly manifest but in some instances, sense of the verse was lost. While the initial meeting between Angelo and Isabella was well constructed, with Lucio (Sarah Peters) playing the part well, coherence was lacking during the later scene in which Angelo propositions Isabella and the subtle interplay between the characters was missed which would have greatly helped the quality of the perfornance.
Comic elements, however, were well played out with Tom Nash  depicting a wonderfully camp and shrill voiced Constable Elbow and addition of the ‘sex scene’ between Mariana and Angelo gave much-needed comic relief inbetween the speech heavy scenes.
Unfortunately, the final act of the play was muddled and for those who did not know the play it may have been confusing. It is in these last scenes that much of the uncertainty about the nature of the play arises and therefore it is the role of the director to navigate the audience through this morally ambiguous minefield. It seemed unclear that any sort of direction had been decided upon and therefore the ending lived up to its reputation as morally uncertain; hardly ideal in such a complicated play.
Though there were occasional moments of brilliancy and the audience were kept amused by slap-stick humor, I found certain elements frustrating and underlying themes overlooked. In any modern re-working of a play there will always be a variety of opinion, but for me it lacked the technical direction that such a complex play needs in order to succeed.