Man’s, not nature’s, best friend? Dog waste linked to reduced biodiversity
By Michelle Leung
Domesticated dogs’ faeces and urine are likely to cause significant and non-negligible damage to wildlife, a study by a Belgian research group reports.
There are around 104 million pet dogs in Europe, meaning nearly 50% of private households own at least one dog. These lovable pets are given protein-rich diets, which have elevated levels of plant macronutrients, including nitrogen and phosphorus. This directly impacts levels of such nutrients in their excretory waste products, i.e. faeces and urine.
In comparison to wild grazers and foragers that are involved in the ecosystem’s natural nutrient recycling, deposited dog waste will cause substantial changes to soil nutrient levels and thus affect plant biodiversity. So, perhaps in this scenario, your beloved pup ‘giving back to nature’ during a walk is not necessarily ideal.
There has been more documentation on the direct mortality, disturbance and disease transmission caused by domesticated dogs. The impact of their role as ‘fertilisers’, however, remains unclear.
The researchers conducted their census across four nature reserves located less than 5km from the city centre in Ghent, Belgium. Over 1.5 years, they counted 1,629 dogs and used this density to estimate nitrogen and phosphorus input from the canine excretory matter.
They calculated an annual average of 11kg of nitrogen per hectare and 5kg of phosphorus per hectare in these peri-urban areas. This is a surprisingly significant amount of macronutrients found, because other sources of pollutants, such as those from farming and industry, contribute 5-25kg of nitrogen per hectare per year.
Picking up solid faecal matter removes almost all phosphorus but only half of the nitrogen
Excess phosphorus eradicates the niche of many endangered species and being a rather immobile mineral nutrient, its legacy can last for centuries. Meanwhile, excess nitrogen contributes to the reduction in species richness. Overall, overfertilization drives the reduction in plant biodiversity which leads to a catastrophic impact on the ecosystem’s food chain.
The researchers found that picking up solid faecal matter removes almost all phosphorus but only half of the nitrogen. On the other hand, urine contains a large fraction of nitrogen found but is more difficult to take away. Importantly, dog urine occurs in concentrated patches, often along designated trails in the nature reserves.
As a comparison, the average nitrogen content in dog urine patches is around 18.7g per litre, whereas that of cattle is only 0.7-10.2g per litre. This high concentration induces a rapid impact on vegetation, with effects noticeable within two days, where available forms of nitrogen for plants, such as nitrates and ammonia, change.
Examining results from the study, the researchers recommended a few solutions to reduce the effects of domestic dogs being avid fertilisers. Nature reserves should enforce rules on leash usage to restrict areas that the dogs can defecate and urinate in. They recommend that leashes should be around two meters long. This way, the majority of the area’s ecosystem can be protected from overfertilization.
Dog owners should also maintain the responsibility of picking up the faeces and not employ the ‘stick and flick’ strategy. This will lower the chances of spreading zoonotic diseases, such as Neospora caninum, to grazing animals. N. caninum, is an intracellular parasite that uses dogs as its host and is a culprit for inducing abortion in deer and grazers.
Management can consider setting up a fenced off-leash dog park nearby the nature reserve, to allow the dogs to roam freely. This could be particularly useful for areas with sensitive oligotrophic ecosystems that have plants adapted for nutrient-poor soils. As a result, high-pressure areas that are crucial for biodiversity conservation can be protected.
Ultimately, educating the public remains the fundamental solution to this problem. To successfully incorporate this knowledge into people’s daily lives, campaigns should be launched to spread awareness of this often neglected fertilization effect of dogs.
Illustration: Adeline Zhao

